Under normal circumstances this should be an outrageous and completely wrong question to ask as well as a wrong assumption to make. But these are not normal circumstances. Clearly. Let me rephrase that. Sadly, my headline is the new normal for Saints supporters. Nothing to see here and business as ...

waste of money. should be throwing that at shiel, not another front-runner in Polec Could not agree more . Shiel is exactly what we need !! Polec is handy but he is not a Dylan Shiel . I realise it's a long shot to even be a chance to get him but IMO I would be doing everything in our power to get ...

Poor trainer and apparently is pretty loose. That’s just wrong. He may have limitations but being a poor trainer is certainly not one of them. On the same topic that is one of the things you’ll see a huge improvement in. Our professionalism at training this year was poor. Will be vastly different n...

SaintPav wrote: ↑Tue 11 Sep 2018 8:39pm What about Hanners?

Hopefully it was just a passing phase

Vazelos wrote: ↑Tue 11 Sep 2018 8:35pm We just offered Dylan Shiel 1.2 to 1.3 million a year for 6-7 years it’s been reported.

IMO if true just get it done !!!

After watching how important Jeremy MCGovern was on the weekend I couldn't help but wonder whether Paddy would suit a similar role down back? They are both similar in their physical make-up and share similar traits in that Paddy reads the play better than most (it's just that no one kicks it to his...

We will be saved from ourselves. Surely. Hannebery and Menzel have recently shown they are not worth a cracker. A Sao not your imported rubbish, but nevertheless not worth seriously considering. I hope we are actually playing mind games, otherwise it is a worry. I don't have a lot of faith in our f...

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Sat 08 Sep 2018 11:54pm I love getting lost in the bush

Can we keep this above the waist line sunshine

Unfortunately if we got rid of all the dead wood we would only have a handful of players left & yep its going to be a long way back . Even a good coach would struggle to get us to a level where we could be competitive in the near future & Richo's got a snow mans chance in hell IMO. :( I'm n...

Going early, but if Kelly has done an ACL here. Do we trade for him this off season even though he can’t play next year? If GWS are under salary cap pressures, they aren’t going to want to pay someone who can’t play for a year and is then out of contact at the end of that season. Could be a bargain...

I didn't handle the Bulldogs winning the flag well...I also didn't handle the Tigers winning it well...too bitter and twisted about our history...but this one I don't really care about anymore...I basically have conceded defeat already...Demons will get theirs before ours...Essendon will win one be...

Unfortunately if we got rid of all the dead wood we would only have a handful of players left & yep its going to be a long way back . Even a good coach would struggle to get us to a level where we could be competitive in the near future & Richo's got a snow mans chance in hell IMO.

Hate is a pretty harsh word I really just dislike all the other clubs equally

We need to recruit players to improve our list & I don't think Menzel is a good fit for us but the bottom line is we need some new talent. Unfortunately these type of players are the only ones we are likely attract because they want to stay in the system an extra few years & it may be their ...

Of those who suited up in the last game of the year there are only 6 I would not consider trading; others if a great offer came and some who we are unlikely to be able to move on and who will therefore stay or be delisted. SO: Should not be traded- Membrey, Steele, Gresham, Steven, Carlisle, Webste...

As much as I was very unhappy with the effort & the game plan but when we hit the front with a minute to go I couldn't watch. I took the mobile & went for a walk & when my wife text me to say we had won it euphoric . I know it was only Gold Coast but being a saints fan for 50 years any w...

Great servant of the club got the best out of what he had to offer & I would like to personally thank him for his contribution to the St.Kilda Football Club. He had his faults & sometimes he made me want to pull my hair out & smash the TV but he gave it everything & you can't ask for...

I have a cabbage in the fridge that is looking like a better option for next year. Is it available? Well I was going to make some kimchi, but for the good of the club I will release the cabbage if it improves our coaching department. Salad days. When I was green in judgment: cold in blood, To say a...

I have already stated that he deserves another year even though I'm not his greatest fan . If he works his butt off next year & can prove he really deserves a better contract I would have no issue . He has been on our list for over 3 years & hasn't really cut the mustard & has played a h...

Thommo loves the saints & has all the right intentions but IMO his time has passed . If he want's to be a mover & a shaker he needs to be on the inside trying to help not on the outside stirring the pot & I doubt he has the numbers or the desire to get back in the ring . All he is doing ...

saint6709 wrote: ↑Tue 04 Sep 2018 8:32pm

stonecold wrote: ↑Tue 04 Sep 2018 8:08pm Channel 7 reporting Brisbane have offered him 3 year deal!!!!!

Maybe he is the jack straight swap with Beames

Gold !!!

I'm a die hard so no matter what I will always be a member until they cease to exist as the St.Kilda Football Club( no mergers ,no relocation) but thats just me . I can understand supporters frustration & if they have had enough & want to call it a day I can understand that too .I'm frustrat...

I'm his biggest critic....Quite seriously...I have made meme's about Jack Lonie. He deserves one year. That is as far as I can stretch it. He had a good last month. He wants multiple years. We don't need the list clogged. I cant see how we can hold onto him if someone else want to give him some mor...

dragit wrote: ↑Mon 03 Sep 2018 9:44pm More useful than Lycett at any rate.

Yeah I'm with you. IMO Lycett is only a bit better than what we already have & as mach as Polec would be a handy pick up 800 grand seems pretty steep but I suppose it's supply & demand & if we don't offer that sort of coin we miss out

If we don't turn around our on field performance IMO It's a really possibility. The ability to attract & keep members & sponsors is a real worry . Trying to keep required players & entice free agents is going to get harder unless you can demonstrate there is a future at the club.The AFL ...