Long and Sinclair two easy misses

This is what stops us from being a decent team and has done for for 4 years

Membreys miss will probably be match losing

You cannot miss that as an AFL Forward... a 12yo would kick that 8/10 times

Membrey has duffed three important shots

Why do we miss easy goals?

Got to stop directing the ball through Bruce v Casboult
Casboult has got him in the air comfortably and Bruce is making him look like Glen Jakovich

It’s not always easy to get more of the ball as a small forward, the GP wouldn’t be to direct much footy through small forwards.

Thing is, you don’t count possessions as a small forward, you make your possessions count!

Didn’t know the MCG had a roof?

No one knows wtf he is going to do with the footy, least of all himself.

He always hangs on to the footy a step too long.

Reason he didn’t kick a goal from the goal square, took too long with the footy.

Gibbons and DeLuca

Showing that great players from the levels below can be really good players at AFL level

BTW
Carlisle is a lazy F***!

This isn’t looking good at the moment.

Who the hell is playing on McGovern?

That’s a soda missed by Membrey, down the other end, goal!

Story of StK

What was Plugger right with?

That Steven had OP in 09 or 10?

He played ok at Sandy for someone with OP... and why would he be playing at all with OP

Armo should definitely played 2009
Steven in 2010

Yes, Selwood has not been in the centre square much this year.

Dunstan is a good signing on the right money... like anyone

Steven did not have OP

He was playing for Sandy at the time and even debuted in R19 for StK

Why would he be playing games if he had OP

Armitage was the one in 09
Got three Brownlow votes in R19
Was dropped a couple of matches later?!
Conditions would have suited him down to the ground too!

We have three tall forwards for next year

Can’t have a second Ruck resting there and not providing Forward half pressure

3 small at least are a must

Jenkins is not much chop

Some absolute rubbish in this thread.

People see what they want to see

Or maybe they’ve just won games they should have won?

And lost vs Adel because that was also expected?

I’m sure he did have a game plan, which Rattan has indicated he’s barely changed.

It’s not 1970

Players who don’t play seniors at all in their first 4 years don’t usually last on the list

The hand bagger call came from the late 80s-mid 90s when they we’re actually a good team. It was a reference to them carrying handbags because they were soft and couldn’t handle the big occasions. Under Blight they basically played an all out attack game, and didn’t defend, which was brilliant again...

There is a perception that Carlisle is a gun, there is also a reality.

We don’t need an intercept marking loose man down back, we need a good Key Defender, who can compete with gun forwards, which he is not.

What, a level headed personality?

How well do you know Harves

Harvey definitely deserved the Brownlow in 97, he was the best player in the AFL that year

Won the
AFLPA MVP
Herald Sun player of the year
ABC footballer of the year

Grant was very good, Harvey was great. Harvey just had a few more stealing votes off him
Burke, Everett, Loewe etc..

Loved watching Dave play

Absolute Warrior!

Should have played 30 more games between 09-11

Lyon had in their absolute prime Reiwoldt, Goddard, Dal Santo, Fisher, Montagna, Milne, Hayes, Baker That is 8 all time greats in their PRIME at the one time Then their were handy or better players like Ray, Gram, Kosi, Gilbert, Jones, Schnieder, Dempster, Blake Another 8 good players, some ending u...

Most overrated player on our list, and that’s saying something because Acres in on the list!

He is at best a bit lazy, at worst disinterested