All of the above will be handy players, will prolly play 100 games plus but none IMO will be the cream and silk you need to challenge Top 4 Can anyone see any of them winning a Rising Star nomination this year? . Like it or not its a gauge of how your kids are going against other teams kids Oh and p...

Whoever we pick MUST be an elite kick....no arguments no compromises

So.."Umpire 23 has no idea" wouldnt have sufficed as a headline?? We must mock the mentally ill?

The Watson case is part of a WIDER investigation that ASADA, WADA the AFL & Essendon signed up to. Part of that deal is that NOTHING will happen until the investigation is completed. Yes, the waters have been muddied by Watson's admission but I think the AFL & Essendon will try to hold firm...

called Roo a "superatar and champion of the game " last week and took the Dees fans to task for booing him On Saturday...and thats just from watching about 5 mins of highlights of both games Hes not perfect but people hear what they wanna hear I guess sticking up for your former boss are ...

Ahh so its OK for Tom to get a couple so long as everyone else gets rubbed out too, preferably for longer.

High contact, low impact, intentional..how can anyone possibly argue with that

Would have been a one weeker but he has priors

Heres a suggestion...dont swing a punch at anyones head 50m off the play..then the chances of you being suspended are greatly reduced Yes Dawes crumpled like a pack of cards..but Tom had the option not to do it. Wasnt a block or a shepherd Silly act that Id hope will be pointed out to him by the sen...

I used to be very cranky at people who left early...but with the plethora of timeslots we now play in, theres legitimate reasons why people might have to get going pre-siren. Saturday twilight especially..wouldnt you rather have people go for 3 1/2 quarters then go off to their other function.. than...

could be the start of the end of our sandy relationship. I would be happy to pay an extra $10 (35k members equate to $350k) if it meant that we could have our own team. Problem is where would be play. Moorabbin playing surfgace is elite..as is LHC, but neither have sufficient facilities to host VFL...

called Roo a "superatar and champion of the game " last week and took the Dees fans to task for booing him On Saturday...and thats just from watching about 5 mins of highlights of both games

Hes not perfect but people hear what they wanna hear I guess

Scotty mentioned in his speech at the 50 year+ Members function that a standalone Reserves side is on the agenda however $$ is the stumbling block

Critically important IMO..Sheesh if the Doggies can afford it..

Jesus....now we have ppl admitting that CLub presidents are casting opinions on the case...and posting it publicly!!

Do we not have any bloody moderators here any more..especially with this case now blown up???

Does the word subjudice not mean anything to anyone??

This thread needs to be shut down

Look at moi, look at moi, look at moi... Piss off. Got anything of value to add? Couldn't be less constructive than this thread has been. Go back and have a read. Whole bunch of people think its rubbish. There's at least three other threads discussing his future but you have to start your own , usi...

Look at moi, look at moi, look at moi...

In: Kosi, MIlera, Wright

Out: Milne, Maister, Saad.

Hell no.anyone who was sitting within a bulls roar of me knows exactly what I thought of the umpiring in that game lol..and they are all valid reasonable questions and the sort of things the Club raised I'm sure Curly however has been on a season long bender blaming every single one of our woes on c...

Constructive criticism of umpiring and the rules is one thing Curlys endless tinfoil hat spaceman consiracy theories are another You hate umpires and think every single one of them have an agenda against St Kilda..we get it! Yep. Are you getting the message at all Curly? Not just from P66 and me. T...

Yay..I've drifted out of everyone's collective psyche after spending way too much time on here for too long

Whoever we get...it CANNOT turn out to be a failed pick...its kinda non negotiable.

Another Fergus Watts Andrew Lovettt or Barry Brooks...and were in deep do-do's..

Constructive criticism of umpiring and the rules is one thing

Curlys endless tinfoil hat spaceman consiracy theories are another

You hate umpires and think every single one of them have an agenda against St Kilda..we get it!

Was just using Darling as an example..point was...we need a kid or two who stamp themselves on the game by Game 50...plenty of other clubs have them...been prolly 12 years for us.

The Club can wish an earlier start time all they like...their is no way the AFL, CH 7 or Foxtel will want it overlapping Ess v Coll. Won't happen in a million years. What about 11.10am Melbourne time? Wouldn't rate as well as 5.40pm but would fit in. I would beleive that the agreement between the A...

50ish games in and a certified gun Anyone care to take a guess at who our next player to do this will be....cos we need (at least) one badly. ...and by gun I don't mean "serviceable payer who averages 16 touches a game" Would be the diff between three and six years in the wilderness IMO.

The Club can wish an earlier start time all they like...their is no way the AFL, CH 7 or Foxtel will want it overlapping Ess v Coll. Won't happen in a million years.

We're going to have to trade for picks this year. Our list in broken up into...ageing players who we either need (Roo, Dal) have zero trade value (Dempster, Fisher) young kids who we need to be part of the next phase...and 22-26 year olds who havent made an impact (Saad, Milera, Maister) Anyone from...