Saintsational Fan Forum - A passionate community of St Kilda Football Club fans discussing news, history, players, trade rumours, results, AFL stats and more.
Sanctorum wrote: ↑Fri 10 Apr 2020 12:28pm
Brendon Goddard deserves to be rated in top 10, also consider the following 3 to warrant inclusion in top 20, in place of Jack Steven, Steven Baker and Sean Dempster:
Justin Koschitzke
Barry Hall
Justin Peckett
As for order of merit, my top 5:
Lockett
Harvey
Riewoldt
Hayes
Goddard
Yeah Steven, Baker and Dempster being in the best 20 players of the last 33 years doesn’t seem to sit well with me either.
As well as the 3 you mentioned above, I think Andrew Thompson and Luke Ball both deserve a look too.
All posters are equal, but some posters are more equal than others.
Sanctorum wrote: ↑Fri 10 Apr 2020 12:28pm
Brendon Goddard deserves to be rated in top 10, also consider the following 3 to warrant inclusion in top 20, in place of Jack Steven, Steven Baker and Sean Dempster:
Justin Koschitzke
Barry Hall
Justin Peckett
As for order of merit, my top 5:
Lockett
Harvey
Riewoldt
Hayes
Goddard
Yeah Steven, Baker and Dempster being in the best 20 players of the last 33 years doesn’t seem to sit well with me either.
As well as the 3 you mentioned above, I think Andrew Thompson and Luke Ball both deserve a look too.
Steven has 4 B&Fs. You may not rate him but history will.
Sanctorum wrote: ↑Fri 10 Apr 2020 12:28pm
Brendon Goddard deserves to be rated in top 10, also consider the following 3 to warrant inclusion in top 20, in place of Jack Steven, Steven Baker and Sean Dempster:
Justin Koschitzke
Barry Hall
Justin Peckett
As for order of merit, my top 5:
Lockett
Harvey
Riewoldt
Hayes
Goddard
Yeah Steven, Baker and Dempster being in the best 20 players of the last 33 years doesn’t seem to sit well with me either.
As well as the 3 you mentioned above, I think Andrew Thompson and Luke Ball both deserve a look too.
Steven has 4 B&Fs. You may not rate him but history will.
And Goddard, Dal Santo, Milne, Montagna and Gehrig have zero between them.
B&Fs are only as good as the team they’re from.
All posters are equal, but some posters are more equal than others.
Sanctorum wrote: ↑Fri 10 Apr 2020 12:28pm
Brendon Goddard deserves to be rated in top 10, also consider the following 3 to warrant inclusion in top 20, in place of Jack Steven, Steven Baker and Sean Dempster:
Justin Koschitzke
Barry Hall
Justin Peckett
You could argue any of those ... or Andrew Thompson or Jason Blake or quite a few others. These lists are just to create debate really.
But Steven deserves his spot, I think, and Baker and Dempster were at least worthy candidates. Not glamorous players, more tough and dependable.
1. Plugger - best player to play the game full stop. The best goal-kicking technique and accuracy ever. Plus the fact the team was so s*** when he played was an even more incredible feat.
2. Harvey
3. Roo
4. Underrated - the best small forward to ever play the game.
Nobody should ever leave us, as evidenced by where Goddard is placed or not placed on people's lists.
People acting like spurned lovers when it was the club that forced his exit.
To place him below Milne for one is a joke.
Just view the three GF's they played in and the answer will be there.
Yes I am aware of Milne's goal-kicking record at Docklands!
