injury list

[Ralphy]

St Kilda
Matt Maguire – foot stress fracture – 2 weeks
Brendan Goddard – knee – 2 weeks
Fraser Gehrig – calf – available
Sean Dempster – cartilage arthroscopy – 2 weeks
Jayden Atard – knee ACL - season
James Gwilt – groin – 2 weeks

[saintbrat]

http://saints.com.au/Season2008/Injurie ... fault.aspx

with expectation or play included.

[Ralphy]

sweet. i just thought id put it here for all

[chook23]

St Kilda
Matt Maguire – foot stress fracture – 2 weeks
Brendan Goddard – knee – 2 weeks
Fraser Gehrig – calf – available
Sean Dempster – cartilage arthroscopy – 2 weeks
Jayden Atard – knee ACL - season
James Gwilt – groin – 2 weeks

Why are Maguire and Goddard listed as 2 weeks?

Should it not be available ??.......are they not expected to play at Scorps getting afl match fit..

[Ralphy]

this is what i got from afl.com.au

i thought id post it here for people but it seems pretty off

[saintspremiers]

this is what i got from afl.com.au

i thought id post it here for people but it seems pretty off

typical crap on an afl sanctioned site.

How can they write Goddard, Knee, 2 weeks when there are no reports from anyone on here that he's injured?

Is that the case, a new injury, or is it a crock???

Anyone know??

[saintbrat]

Why are Maguire and Goddard listed as 2 weeks?

Should it not be available ??.......are they not expected to play at Scorps getting afl match fit..

would it be because the saints are not looking at even considering them for the AFL team for atleast that-- getting more practice/ game time and physical preparation with Casey.

[yipper]

St Kilda
Matt Maguire – foot stress fracture – 2 weeks
Brendan Goddard – knee – 2 weeks
Fraser Gehrig – calf – available
Sean Dempster – cartilage arthroscopy – 2 weeks
Jayden Atard – knee ACL - season
James Gwilt – groin – 2 weeks

Why are Maguire and Goddard listed as 2 weeks?

Should it not be available ??.......are they not expected to play at Scorps getting afl match fit..

Both definately playing at Scorps - Goddard has had 3 games now, Goose 2 and a half games. Reports are that one or both will come in for Rd 3 v Doggies. But that list above could indicate they will each get 2 more weeks at the Scorps.

[Gilbert=Legend]

Goddard and Goose are being considered to play this week against Carlton, they played for Casey twice all ready

[chook23]

St Kilda
Matt Maguire – foot stress fracture – 2 weeks
Brendan Goddard – knee – 2 weeks
Fraser Gehrig – calf – available
Sean Dempster – cartilage arthroscopy – 2 weeks
Jayden Atard – knee ACL - season
James Gwilt – groin – 2 weeks

Why are Maguire and Goddard listed as 2 weeks?

Should it not be available ??.......are they not expected to play at Scorps getting afl match fit..

Both definately playing at Scorps - Goddard has had 3 games now, Goose 2 and a half games. Reports are that one or both will come in for Rd 3 v Doggies. But that list above could indicate they will each get 2 more weeks at the Scorps.

That is my point Yipper

Normally not listed in injuries if available to play scorps

seems they are guessing how far from senior selection.

journ on afl site not aware of normal practice that only in injured list if UNAVAILABLE for both afl and vfl

[GrumpyOne]

There's one they forgot:

A Hamill - 2 Weeks.

[Solar]

I am glad we are not putting players without a preseason straight into the seniors. The likes of goose and BJ are doing their preseason cup right now.

Can't help but feel we might be a little too top heavy against the dogs if both BJ and maguire come in

[Goose is king]

I like that one gumpy

[casey scorp]

St Kilda
Matt Maguire – foot stress fracture – 2 weeks
Brendan Goddard – knee – 2 weeks
Fraser Gehrig – calf – available
Sean Dempster – cartilage arthroscopy – 2 weeks
Jayden Atard – knee ACL - season
James Gwilt – groin – 2 weeks

Why are Maguire and Goddard listed as 2 weeks?

Should it not be available ??.......are they not expected to play at Scorps getting afl match fit..

Both definately playing at Scorps - Goddard has had 3 games now, Goose 2 and a half games. Reports are that one or both will come in for Rd 3 v Doggies. But that list above could indicate they will each get 2 more weeks at the Scorps.

That is my point Yipper

Normally not listed in injuries if available to play scorps

seems they are guessing how far from senior selection.

journ on afl site not aware of normal practice that only in injured list if UNAVAILABLE for both afl and vfl

Correct. Maguire, Goddard, Dempster & Gwilt all played last week for the Scorps (and Maguire & Goddard had already played a couple previously). They're available - just not AFL Match ready (although Goddard must be getting close).

The real list looks better:

Fraser Gehrig – calf – available
Jayden Atard – knee ACL - season