VOTES vs Collingwood

[battye]

It's a tough one today, for the wrong reasons sadly...

5. Hayes
4. Pattison
3. Fisher
2. Riewoldt
1. Steven

[Badlands]

5. Goddard
4. Montagna
3. Hayes
2. Geary
1. Pattison

[markinUSA]

Very hard to give 5 votes...

5. Fisher
4. Hayes
3. Gilbert
2 Goddard
1 Montagna

[RoseInOz]

5. Fisher
4. Gilbert
3. Montagna
2. Hayes
1. Gardiner

[BigMart]

Goddard

and NO other player

BTW - L.Hayes had his pants pulled down by Luke Ball....he worked hard but did NOTHING damaging...interesting votes above

[saintkid]

Goddard

and NO other player

BTW - L.Hayes had his pants pulled down by Luke Ball....he worked hard but did NOTHING damaging...interesting votes above

I agree BigMart.

[Badlands]

Goddard

and NO other player

BTW - L.Hayes had his pants pulled down by Luke Ball....he worked hard but did NOTHING damaging...interesting votes above

What rubbish.

Lenny did some very good things that could have been damaging had others been more effective. Ffs he can't win the hard ball shovel it out and then get on the end of his own work to run and kick inside 50, then find himself on the lead, go back and slot it.

I'm not saying he outplayed Ball, but would've thought he did enough to figure in our top 5 on a very tough day to find players who outpointed their opponent.

[battye]

Goddard

and NO other player

BTW - L.Hayes had his pants pulled down by Luke Ball....he worked hard but did NOTHING damaging...interesting votes above

What rubbish.

Lenny did some very good things that could have been damaging had others been more effective. Ffs he can't win the hard ball shovel it out and then get on the end of his own work to run and kick inside 50, then find himself on the lead, go back and slot it.

I'm not saying he outplayed Ball, but would've thought he did enough to figure in our top 5 on a very tough day to find players who outpointed their opponent.

I don't think Goddard was damaging today, not our worst - but I don't think he was among our best.

[bergsone]

5 Goddard
4 Gardiner
3 Jones
2 Fisher
1 Blake

[noob]

5 Goddard
4 Fisher
3 Montagna
2 Hayes
1 Pattison

amazing how one week its hard to fit so many good contributors and then the next trying to actually find someone that was good.

[stkildathunda]

5. Montagna
4. Fisher
3. Gilbert
2. Gwilt
1. Pattison

[GoTheTorp]

5:Swan
4:Shaw
3:Ball
2:Pendlebury
1:Didak

[st_Trav_ofWA]

5 . Gwilt
4 . Lenny
3 . Patto
2 . Steven
1 . joey

[meher baba]

Interesting to see Fisher and Gilbert poll well on here when one considers that between them they gave away 3-4 crucial goals in the first half which basically put us out of the game.

These two rack up plenty of possessions each week, largely when playing loose at the back. Difficult to avoid getting touches and marks in those roles, but the stats don't really tell the whole story IMO.

But, to be fair, I only saw the first half. Perhaps the Sams engineered a massive comeback after half time (what was the final score anyway?)

[battye]

Interesting to see Fisher and Gilbert poll well on here when one considers that between them they gave away 3-4 crucial goals in the first half which basically put us out of the game.

These two rack up plenty of possessions each week, largely when playing loose at the back. Difficult to avoid getting touches and marks in those roles, but the stats don't really tell the whole story IMO.

But, to be fair, I only saw the first half. Perhaps the Sams engineered a massive comeback after half time (what was the final score anyway?)

I didn't give Gilbert any votes today, like most of the Saints today he had a shocker. Racked up a few possessions, but just seemed wrongfooted on too many occasions and panicked a bit under pressure.

I gave Fisher a few, although I was reluctant. He got a lot of easy possessions but made a few bad errors. Having said that he did intercept a few balls, got into good positions, etc and on a day where everyone was down, I guess you could say he was "less down" than others.

[stinger]

5. sam fisher
4. lenny
3. peake
2 bj
1 joey

[dcstkfc]

5 Montagna
4 Gilbert
3 Fisher
2 Hayes
1 Geary

[dals_da_bomb]

5.Fisher
4.Gwilt
3.Goddard
2.Hayes
1.Joey

[st_Trav_ofWA]

5 Montagna
4 Gilbert
3 Fisher
2 Hayes
1 Geary

geary ???? really ?

i mean hes a good kid and i do like the way he go's about it but i felt he had a shocker today

[dcstkfc]

5 Montagna
4 Gilbert
3 Fisher
2 Hayes
1 Geary

geary ???? really ?

i mean hes a good kid and i do like the way he go's about it but i felt he had a shocker today

Had a dip- 20 possessions, 6 tackles and a goal, disposal lets him down but most of the boys missed targets today

[Sainternist]

Fisher
Steven
Gilbert
Pattison
Peake

[saintnick12]

5:Swan
4:Shaw
3:Ball
2:Pendlebury
1:Didak

Hilarious

[saints11]

5.Montagna
4.Goddard
3.Fisher
2.Gilbert
1.Hayes

[saintly]

It's a tough one today, for the wrong reasons sadly...

5. Hayes
4. Pattison
3. Fisher
2. Riewoldt
1. Steven

what did pattison do?

[dcstkfc]

It's a tough one today, for the wrong reasons sadly...

5. Hayes
4. Pattison
3. Fisher
2. Riewoldt
1. Steven

what did pattison do?

Contested well and psychologically he seems better because you weren't expecting better.