Guess at this weeks ins and outs

plugger66 · Post: # 821522Post **plugger66** » Thu 17 Sep 2009 8:15am

Alright. Second biggest game for the year or even an arguement that it is the most important so what do we do.

The only 2 in trouble would be Eddy and Zac. Zac due to match ups. I will go with no change.

karnaby · Post: # 821529Post **karnaby** » Thu 17 Sep 2009 8:51am

I've said the same elsewhere, but I suspect Geary might come in for Zac.

saintly · Post: # 821537Post **saintly** » Thu 17 Sep 2009 9:16am

karnaby wrote:I've said the same elsewhere, but I suspect Geary might come in for Zac.

why change the structure ?

that would be silly by them and seriuosuly doubt that would happen.

the only time the saints have changed their structure all year was that first time when Kosi was out for a week. The saints did not replace him with another tall foward but brought in Eddy. it did not workvery well, the saints won't change their structure during the finals.

Solar · Post: # 821539Post **Solar** » Thu 17 Sep 2009 9:21am

eddy out, geary in

raph plays forward and geary takes the small back role

karnaby · Post: # 821543Post **karnaby** » Thu 17 Sep 2009 9:41am

saintly wrote:
karnaby wrote:I've said the same elsewhere, but I suspect Geary might come in for Zac.
why change the structure ?

that would be silly by them and seriuosuly doubt that would happen.

the only time the saints have changed their structure all year was that first time when Kosi was out for a week. The saints did not replace him with another tall foward but brought in Eddy. it did not workvery well, the saints won't change their structure during the finals.

I accept your premise about our structure, however I doubt that there is really a good match up for Zac so I wonder if the horse for courses theory might come into play.

I believe that footscray will try to change things up at some stage, if not for the whole game. I think that it is fair to assume that trying to use pace as a means to beat us is something they'll try. Geary can potentially address that better than Zac.

Eastern · Post: # 821550Post **Eastern** » Thu 17 Sep 2009 10:00am

NO CHANGE !!

spert · Post: # 821554Post **spert** » Thu 17 Sep 2009 10:03am

I guess you wouldn't tinker with the best backline in the comp, and the only thing I could see to improve on, is getting a few more goals out of the forwards and midfield -maybe Geary or Gwilt in the mix somewhere

SainterK · Post: # 821574Post **SainterK** » Thu 17 Sep 2009 10:31am

In: Gwilt Out: Eddy

JABBER · Post: # 821584Post **JABBER** » Thu 17 Sep 2009 10:45am

In Dempster

Out Eddy

hard to fit 31 into 22 I Caught the end of the news on the radio where they said a fast irishman would play Do they mean Begley or M Clarke of Collingwood

Let RL pick the team and not us

Spinner · Post: # 821598Post **Spinner** » Thu 17 Sep 2009 11:09am

I'm tipping no change...But if there is one, I wouldn't be surprised to see Dempster in for Eddy.

SaintHomer · Thu 17 Sep 2009 11:13am

I think it'll be NO CHANGE

I think Minson will go forward and there's Zac's matchup.

Geary, Gwilt and Armitage very unlucky. And feel sorry for Maxy.

Junior · Post: # 821712Post **Junior** » Thu 17 Sep 2009 1:30pm

In Dempster
Out Eddy

saint vince · Thu 17 Sep 2009 2:38pm

SainterK wrote:In: Gwilt Out: Eddy

+1 for me.

Guess at this weeks ins and outs

Guess at this weeks ins and outs

guess tis weeks ins and outs