McEvoy

Stillwaiting · Sun 28 Mar 2010 4:55pm

I have not seen any of the game (yet).

Would like to know how Ben went, and would he still get a gam with Kingy, Gardy available?

wasaintsfan · Sun 28 Mar 2010 4:56pm

he was pretty quiet for the night.. but against sydney its to be expected from most players...

battye · Post: # 897794Post **battye** » Sun 28 Mar 2010 5:47pm

King had more impact I thought. Based on form, if one of the ruckmen was to make way for Gardiner it would have to be McEvoy.

Zed · Post: # 897816Post **Zed** » Sun 28 Mar 2010 6:17pm

if Gardi comes back for Rd 2 then big Mac will play FF assuming Kosi gets rubbed out

plugger66 · Post: # 897853Post **plugger66** » Sun 28 Mar 2010 7:34pm

Zed wrote:if Gardi comes back for Rd 2 then big Mac will play FF assuming Kosi gets rubbed out

What will that actually achieve?

bigcarl · Post: # 897854Post **bigcarl** » Sun 28 Mar 2010 7:35pm

plugger66 wrote:
Zed wrote:if Gardi comes back for Rd 2 then big Mac will play FF assuming Kosi gets rubbed out
What will that actually achieve?

so who should play ff?

Bernard Shakey · Sun 28 Mar 2010 7:37pm

bigcarl wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Zed wrote:if Gardi comes back for Rd 2 then big Mac will play FF assuming Kosi gets rubbed out
What will that actually achieve?
so who should play ff?

Paul Cahill.

plugger66 · Post: # 897859Post **plugger66** » Sun 28 Mar 2010 7:39pm

Bernard Shakey wrote:
bigcarl wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Zed wrote:if Gardi comes back for Rd 2 then big Mac will play FF assuming Kosi gets rubbed out
What will that actually achieve?
so who should play ff?
Paul Cahill.

No. I think MG will probably play but I think we should give Heyne a go.

bigcarl · Post: # 897866Post **bigcarl** » Sun 28 Mar 2010 7:41pm

plugger66 wrote:
Bernard Shakey wrote:
bigcarl wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Zed wrote:if Gardi comes back for Rd 2 then big Mac will play FF assuming Kosi gets rubbed out
What will that actually achieve?
so who should play ff?
Paul Cahill.
No. I think MG will probably play but I think we should give Heyne a go.

did both cahill and heyne play for sandringham on the weekend and how did they go, just out of interest?

super dooper · Sun 28 Mar 2010 9:37pm

battye wrote:King had more impact I thought. Based on form, if one of the ruckmen was to make way for Gardiner it would have to be McEvoy.

Pardon! Did you watch the same game and or preseason that i have.

Whenever Macca was in the ruck i thought there was so much more control than when King was in the ruck.

Kings efforts around the ground were woeful imo - He barely got off the ground in ruck contests and his marking above his head leaves a lot left to be desired.

Macca is our future, we must play him!!

saint66au · Post: # 897963Post **saint66au** » Sun 28 Mar 2010 9:43pm

If Kosi is rubbed out Gardy will come in...he and King will ruck with Mac playing deep forward with the odd run in the ruck (the "Kosi role" if you like)

All IMO

Bernard Shakey · Sun 28 Mar 2010 9:48pm

When Gardiner comes in King will drop out and stick to his main role of ruck coach.

maverick · Post: # 897968Post **maverick** » Sun 28 Mar 2010 9:52pm

Bernard Shakey wrote:When Gardiner comes in King will drop out and stick to his main role of ruck coach.

I think he probably needs to on two counts...

maverick · Post: # 897971Post **maverick** » Sun 28 Mar 2010 9:53pm

plugger66 wrote:
Bernard Shakey wrote:
bigcarl wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Zed wrote:if Gardi comes back for Rd 2 then big Mac will play FF assuming Kosi gets rubbed out
What will that actually achieve?
so who should play ff?
Paul Cahill.
No. I think MG will probably play but I think we should give Heyne a go.

Why Heyne, gut feel or track form?
Clearly can't be from the waste of time prccy games