MRP and Goose

On the Bench · Mon 03 May 2010 9:05pm

Do the MRP still think Goose plays for the Saints?

How can a player going for the ball get 2 weeks? (1 if he pleads guilty and acceptd the ban)

I was thinking it was becoming a bit more consistant, even though David Hille's let off in Round 1 was probaly incorrect.

Source: http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/ ... fault.aspx

"First-year Lion and former Saint Matt Maguire has been charged for engaging in rough conduct against Sydney Swan Jude Bolton.

The incident drew 225 points and a two-match sanction, but with an early plea he can accept a one-match penalty, subject to confirmation he had a clean record in the VFL last year."

Bernard Shakey · Mon 03 May 2010 9:25pm

Should challenge and will get off, just a clash of heads.

Stillwaiting · Mon 03 May 2010 9:34pm

He gets 2 and fletcher gets off again

rexy · Post: # 917283Post **rexy** » Mon 03 May 2010 9:37pm

Bernard Shakey wrote:Should challenge and will get off, just a clash of heads.

agree

Milan Faletic · Mon 03 May 2010 9:38pm

Bernard Shakey wrote:Should challenge and will get off, just a clash of heads.

Spot on, Bernard. Just saw it on One HD. The MRP need to lift their game.

How Fletcher gets off and Goose gets two is beyond me.

jonesy · Post: # 917313Post **jonesy** » Mon 03 May 2010 10:21pm

Could be the worst decision I've ever seen...and that's saying something

*Also hurts my supercoach side!

Saintsfan · Post: # 917318Post **Saintsfan** » Mon 03 May 2010 10:36pm

Milan Faletic wrote:
Bernard Shakey wrote:Should challenge and will get off, just a clash of heads.
Spot on, Bernard. Just saw it on One HD. The MRP need to lift their game.

How Fletcher gets off and Goose gets two is beyond me.

Fletcher seems to be up multiple years but somehow escapes everything. Mind you his indiscretions are never severe

Moods · Post: # 917322Post **Moods** » Mon 03 May 2010 10:44pm

Just saw what happened with Goose on 'On the Couch' - am absolutely staggered that Goose got any weeks for that.

remboy · Post: # 917332Post **remboy** » Mon 03 May 2010 10:53pm

First time I've ever heard of a player being suspended for getting knocked out.

Otiman · Post: # 917353Post **Otiman** » Mon 03 May 2010 11:20pm

The jumper punch and Kosi's 'shirtfront' would have received attention any other week. I guess they're evening up the shocking umpiring over the weekend, or perhaps fear that taking out two more of our stars would make the game even uglier.

Winmarvellous · Tue 04 May 2010 12:50am

Since when has Kosi been one of our stars

AnythingsPossibleSaints · Tue 04 May 2010 12:06pm

Otiman wrote:The jumper punch and Kosi's 'shirtfront' would have received attention any other week. I guess they're evening up the shocking umpiring over the weekend, or perhaps fear that taking out two more of our stars would make the game even uglier.

Spot on. BJ is very fortunate and Kosi might like to stop trying to bump guys. He's not co-ordinated enough to miss their heads every time.

Ice Wolf · Post: # 917485Post **Ice Wolf** » Tue 04 May 2010 12:28pm

AnythingsPossibleSaints wrote:
Otiman wrote:The jumper punch and Kosi's 'shirtfront' would have received attention any other week. I guess they're evening up the shocking umpiring over the weekend, or perhaps fear that taking out two more of our stars would make the game even uglier.
Spot on. BJ is very fortunate and Kosi might like to stop trying to bump guys. He's not co-ordinated enough to miss their heads every time.

On the other hand hes also not co-ordinated enough to hit their heads every time so i say keep it up.

plugger66 · Post: # 917553Post **plugger66** » Tue 04 May 2010 2:39pm

Goose got 2 because the other guy had the ball and Goose chose to bump and if you take that option you also take the consequences.

Goose is king · Tue 04 May 2010 6:14pm

He is still King

saintbrat · Post: # 917717Post **saintbrat** » Tue 04 May 2010 6:19pm

goose is appealing- will be heard tomorrow

stinger · Post: # 917722Post **stinger** » Tue 04 May 2010 6:30pm

plugger66 wrote:Goose got 2 because the other guy had the ball and Goose chose to bump and if you take that option you also take the consequences.

you obviously didn't see it......both going for the ball....clash of heads....pure accident......nothing to answer for ...imhfo......

stinger · Post: # 917733Post **stinger** » Tue 04 May 2010 6:56pm

for the record matty agrees with me....

"Brisbane defender Matt Maguire will front the tribunal on Wednesday to challenge a level two rough conduct charge against Sydney's Jude Bolton.

Maguire will be suspended for a week if the tribunal finds against him, the same penalty on offer for an early guilty plea."

saintbrat · Post: # 917734Post **saintbrat** » Tue 04 May 2010 7:00pm

will be heard tomorrow diue to him having his cheek bone fixed today from the clash...

saintspremiers · Tue 04 May 2010 9:11pm

Goose is king wrote:He is still King

King wears number 2 for us.

Goose is gone.

Move on.

plugger66 · Post: # 917891Post **plugger66** » Wed 05 May 2010 8:01am

stinger wrote:
plugger66 wrote:Goose got 2 because the other guy had the ball and Goose chose to bump and if you take that option you also take the consequences.

you obviously didn't see it......both going for the ball....clash of heads....pure accident......nothing to answer for ...imhfo......

Sorry who didnt see it. Bolton had the ball and was running with it and about to kick it and Goose ran at him to bump him off the kick. Accidently hit him in the head. Hope he gets off but i am unsure what you were watching.

groupie1 · Post: # 917894Post **groupie1** » Wed 05 May 2010 8:20am

remboy wrote:First time I've ever heard of a player being suspended for getting knocked out.

Like your tag
Opinions are like arseholes; everybody's got one, and they're usually full of s***.

plugger66 · Post: # 918204Post **plugger66** » Wed 05 May 2010 8:21pm

Poor Goose failed to get off but at least he still only got one game. May have missed anyway because of his cheekbone.

casey scorp · Thu 06 May 2010 12:35am

MRP have been after Goose since he incited Barry Hall to punch him during play in the prelim.

Milan Faletic · Thu 06 May 2010 12:38am

plugger66 wrote:Poor Goose failed to get off but at least he still only got one game. May have missed anyway because of his cheekbone.

Bloody ridiculous.