Coaches Votes 2011

[saintbrat]

Rd 1 vs Cats
announced on " The Insiders"
Hayes, Dal santo and Dawson amongst them.

Geelong vs St. Kilda

8 Corey (Geel)

7 Enright (Geel)

5 Hayes (St K)

4 Scarlett (Geel)

3 Dal Santo (St K)

2 Dawson (St K)

1 Lonergan (Geel)
http://www.aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14 ... 74038b9fb5

[Spinner]

Corey played on goddard.. Enright on Milne from memory.

[PJ]

Corey played on goddard.. Enright on Milne from memory.

Milney usually gets the attention but I think BJ will start to find a few more followers since his 2010 final series.

[saintbrat]

Rd 2 vs Tigers
AFLCA Champion Player of the Year votes
Tuesday, April 05, 2011 - 12:00 PM
St. Kilda vs Richmond

10 Deledio (Rich)

8 Grigg (Rich)

4 Martin (Rich)

4 Armitage (St K)

4 Milne (St K)



http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ ... 2100782f9b

[saintbrat]

Rd 3 votes
St. Kilda vs Essendon

10 Watson (Ess)

6 Lonergan (Ess)

4 Bellchambers (Ess)

4 Fletcher (Ess)

2 Winderlich (Ess)

2 Hurley (Ess)

1 Hocking (Ess)

1 Gram (St K)

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ ... b92805bd6c

[desertsaint]

b.o.g every game played on goddard?

[perfectionist]

Jimmy must have given Grammy a vote.

[plugger66]

Jimmy must have given Grammy a vote.

Or maybe many on here have no idea.

[Bernard Shakey]

Jimmy must have given Grammy a vote.

Or maybe many on here have no idea.

He still can't kick.

[spert]

Gram for captain!

[saintbrat]

Round 5 votes
Brisbane Lions v St Kilda
9 Daniel Merrett (Bris)
9 Leigh Montagna (StK)
5 Jed Adcock (Bris)
3 Mitch Clark (Bris)
2 Jack Redden (Bris)
1 Farren Ray (StK)
1 Adam Schneider (StK)

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/ ... fault.aspx

[saintbrat]

Rd 6
Adelaide v St Kilda

9 Scott Thompson (Adel)

7 Sam Jacobs (Adel)

4 Kurt Tippett (Adel)

3 Luke Thompson (Adel)

3 Richard Douglas (Adel)

2 Nick Dal Santo (St K)

1 David Armitage (St K)

1 Patrick Dangerfield (Adel)

[bergholt]

saints leaderboard:

9 Leigh Montagna (votes in 1 game)
5 David Armitage (2), Nick Dal Santo (2), Lenny Hayes (1)
4 Stephen Milne (1)
2 Zac Dawson (1)
1 Jason Gram (1), Farren Ray (1), Adam Schneider (1)

lenny hayes still sitting equal second for us, having played basically one game. armo and dal doing their best to fill that spot.

[saintbrat]

rd 7 interesting
St. Kilda vs Carlton

10 Gibbs (Carl)

5 Carrazzo (Carl)

4 Fisher (St K)

3 Yarran (Carl)

3 Murphy (Carl)

2 Jamison (Carl)

2 Judd (Carl)

1 Warnock (Carl)

http://www.aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14 ... 4a82fc9ad1

[markinUSA]

Milne didn't get a single vote for kicking four goals?
And we came within 3 points, but only one of our players got a vote?
Seems very odd.

[bergholt]

Milne didn't get a single vote for kicking four goals?
And we came within 3 points, but only one of our players got a vote?
Seems very odd.

half the votes come from the coaching staff of each side, so i guess our coaches didn't rate our players.

[Spinner]

Milne didn't get a single vote for kicking four goals?
And we came within 3 points, but only one of our players got a vote?
Seems very odd.

half the votes come from the coaching staff of each side, so i guess our coaches didn't rate our players.

Lyon was asked this. Said the spoils went to the winners.

BOG again goes to the player tagging Goddard...

[Dr Spaceman]

BOG again goes to the player tagging Goddard...

Does that happen because that player is actually BOG, or because Goddard is simply not playing, or being allowed to play, like Goddard?

[borderbarry]

saints leaderboard:

9 Leigh Montagna (votes in 1 game)
5 David Armitage (2), Nick Dal Santo (2), Lenny Hayes (1)
4 Stephen Milne (1)Sam Fisher (1)
2 Zac Dawson (1)
1 Jason Gram (1), Farren Ray (1), Adam Schneider (1)

lenny hayes still sitting equal second for us, having played basically one game. armo and dal doing their best to fill that spot

[borderbarry]

So far in 6 games Saints have only earnt 37 votes, and only polled on 12 occasions. Whereas in the Carlton game alone 6 Carlton players polled for a total of 26 votes. as against one Saint for 4 votes. Remember we lost by 3 points. I think maybe our coaches need to lift their game a bit.

[Bernard Shakey]

So far in 6 games Saints have only earnt 37 votes, and only polled on 12 occasions. Whereas in the Carlton game alone 6 Carlton players polled for a total of 26 votes. as against one Saint for 4 votes. Remember we lost by 3 points. I think maybe our coaches need to lift their game a bit.

Sounds like they're pretty honest. Would you prefer they just name players who haven't performed to the required standard?

[saintbrat]

Round 8
Hawthorn vs St. Kilda

8 Franklin (Haw)

8 Lewis (Haw)

6 Roughead (Haw)

4 Hodge (Haw)

3 Fisher (St K)

1 Savage (Haw)

[saintbrat]

http://www.aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14 ... 2e9bc26ce9

Finaly a 10 for a Saint and top three for game
St Kilda v Melbourne

10 Leigh Montagna (St K)

7 Brendon Goddard (St K)

6 Nick Riewoldt (St K)

3 Stefan Martin (Melb)

2 James Gwilt (St K)

1 Sam Fisher (St K)

1 Jordan Gysberts (Melb)

[Bernard Shakey]

Can't argue with those.

[Spinner]

BOG again goes to the player tagging Goddard...

Does that happen because that player is actually BOG, or because Goddard is simply not playing, or being allowed to play, like Goddard?

Just saw this...

Thinks its a bit of both.

Delideo got a bit of the ball, as did watson.