No changes!

[dragit]

Milne & Rohan the subs.

Very odd upgrading Shenton and not playing him.

[plugger66]

Milne & Rohan the subs.

Very odd upgrading Shenton and not playing him.

More odd having Milne as sub. Either in the 21 or out of the 22.

[clarky449]

It's Watters, everything is odd

[saintspremiers]

And Gilbo straight in.

Shenton should be playing.

Watters is struggling.

[gringo]

I'm too traumatised by watching the GF replay on footy flashbacks to care.

[plugger66]

I'm too traumatised by watching the GF replay on footy flashbacks to care.

Do like putting pins in your eyes for fun?

[bigcarl]

I'm too traumatised by watching the GF replay on footy flashbacks to care.

Are you some sort of masochist?

[Con Gorozidis]

Disappointed for Shaggy
Dont see any point not giving him 3 games so we can assess him.

What do we gain playing Gilbo? hes contracted for next year anyway, underdone and we cant finish higher than 3rd bottom.

Strange behaviour. Does SW still think hes a chance to make the 8?

If Shaggy doesnt play next week Ill go feral.

[saintbob]

An absolute shocking decision naming Milney as the sub, play the f****** kids!!!

Can't even begin to figure this decision out!!!

[whiskers3614]

Maybe avoiding gifting all farewell games on the same week?

[sunsaint]

As much as Im in the play the kids camp, I have not seen shenton.
... is it more the point, the bigger bodies of the swans & the tight ground, SW feels more inclined to throw gilbert at them.
yes he has one more year on contract, but that doesnt mean he will be with us next year.

[Trev from the Bush]

And Gilbo straight in.

Shenton should be playing.

Watters is struggling.

And Shenton's claim to fame is.....what?

We've badly missed Gilbert's run out of the backline this season, great that he's back. Need his height, run and experience down back.

[matrix]

gee waste of time playing milne as the sub ffs

imo

[mad saint guy]

So what is to gain from

1. Upgrading Shenton and not playing him
2. Playing Gilbert cold after a long layoff in a meaningless game
3. Playing Milne as sub

Is there any logic whatsoever behind any of these decisions? Or is Watters just trolling the AFL and saints fans?

[WinnersOnly]

So what is to gain from

1. Upgrading Shenton and not playing him
2. Playing Gilbert cold after a long layoff in a meaningless game
3. Playing Milne as sub

Is there any logic whatsoever behind any of these decisions? Or is Watters just trolling the AFL and saints fans?

Agree totally just another example of Watters poor rationale with his selections. The only reason Gilbert should be playing if he is trade bait at seasons end, even so if they break him today it will increasing ridiculous! Why bother updating Shenton then not playing him the poor bugger !

[plugger66]

So what is to gain from

1. Upgrading Shenton and not playing him
2. Playing Gilbert cold after a long layoff in a meaningless game
3. Playing Milne as sub

Is there any logic whatsoever behind any of these decisions? Or is Watters just trolling the AFL and saints fans?

Agree totally just another example of Watters poor rationale with his selections. The only reason Gilbert should be playing if he is trade bait at seasons end, even so if they break today it will increasing ridiculous! Why bother updating Shenton then not playing him the poor bugger !

Not sure I agree with the last statement. i think the coaching staff would have explained why they upgrading him but wont be playing him. Dont think he just looked in the paper for his name. A couple of strange selections though. The Milne sub thing is the most confusing IMO.

[gringo]

Oh well survived the drawn GF replay now to watch us get towelled by the swans.