Changes for next week

[coopergrech]

In : White (Debut) , Jones , Shents , Saunders
Out : Bruce(Inj) , Billings(Inj) , Ross , Murdoch

[8856brother]

In: White Tezza Saunders
Out: Bruce & Billings (inj) Murdoch

[Beno88]

In : White (Debut) , Jones , Shents , Saunders
Out : Bruce(Inj) , Billings(Inj) , Ross , Murdoch

Drop Seb Ross?!?! The guy who had 19 touches at 80% efficiency, 5 marks, 4 tackles, kicked a goal and was listed in our best three players?

Come on.

[The Redeemer]

In : White (Debut) , Jones , Shents , Saunders
Out : Bruce(Inj) , Billings(Inj) , Ross , Murdoch

How does Murdoch miss? He played and sub and kicked a goal...

Ross stays because he played well.

Jones never plays again.

White plays because why not?

[Saint wagga]

Very early in the week...but here we go.
Out: Bruce (inj)
Billings (inj)

In: White (Debut)
Saunders or Minchi

[sax]

Out: Bruce (inj), Billings, (inj), Murdoch
In: White, Acres, Saunders

[thejiggingsaint]

I thought the idea was to get game time into the KIDS, so on that criteria, CJ runs out for Sandy again until season's end.

[Toy Saint]

Out: Bruce (inj), Billings, (inj), Murdoch
In: White, Acres, Saunders

Sounds reasonable, but I'd keep Murdoch and give Schnieder a rest.

Is Acres ready?

[longtimesaint]

Out: Bruce (inj), Billings, (inj), Murdoch
In: White, Acres, Saunders

Sounds reasonable, but I'd keep Murdoch and give Schnieder a rest.

Is Acres ready?

Schneider was the highest StKilda ranked player per the Herald Sun

[PJ]

Out Bruce and Billings

In Roberton and White

Think Gwilty may go forward again

[stinger]

In : White (Debut) , Jones , Shents , Saunders
Out : Bruce(Inj) , Billings(Inj) , Ross , Murdoch

why do you want to drop ross...did you watch the game??...he was in our best i/2 dozen players ffs....

[chook23]

Out Bruce and Billings

In Roberton and White

Think Gwilty may go forward again

If white came in..............Gwilt to play back

Bruce/Gwilt have played both ends

White would only play fwd at this stage.

[PJ]

Out Bruce and Billings

In Roberton and White

Think Gwilty may go forward again

If white came in..............Gwilt to play back

Bruce/Gwilt have played both ends

White would only play fwd at this stage.

Both Bruce and Billing started forward on Sunday. I'd replace them directly with Gwilt and White and put Roberton down back where Jimmy started.

[plugger66]

Out Bruce and Billings

In Roberton and White

Think Gwilty may go forward again

If white came in..............Gwilt to play back

Bruce/Gwilt have played both ends

White would only play fwd at this stage.

Both Bruce and Billing started forward on Sunday. I'd replace them directly with Gwilt and White and put Roberton down back where Jimmy started.

Arent we a bit top heavy in the forward line then. Think the ball would struggle to stay in our forward line because of lack of pace.

[chook23]

Out Bruce and Billings

In Roberton and White

Think Gwilty may go forward again

If white came in..............Gwilt to play back

Bruce/Gwilt have played both ends

White would only play fwd at this stage.

Both Bruce and Billing started forward on Sunday. I'd replace them directly with Gwilt and White and put Roberton down back where Jimmy started.

Billings would be replaced by a similar type(size)

[PJ]

Out Bruce and Billings

In Roberton and White

Think Gwilty may go forward again

If white came in..............Gwilt to play back

Bruce/Gwilt have played both ends

White would only play fwd at this stage.

Both Bruce and Billing started forward on Sunday. I'd replace them directly with Gwilt and White and put Roberton down back where Jimmy started.

Arent we a bit top heavy in the forward line then. Think the ball would struggle to stay in our forward line because of lack of pace.

Could be but I'd imagine that Jimmy would be able to work defensively to hold the ball in and I really can't see a direct replacement for Billings other than Saunders (who I think needs another pre-season). I haven't seen Spencer play live but by all reports he's fairly quick so really it's a suck it and see approach.

[saintbob]

Out: Billings & Bruce

In: White & Acres

[SemperFidelis]

With Billings gone, is Minch a chance? Or has the decision been made on him?

He has some kind of X factor. I'd like to have seen more of him this year, but it may be too late.

[Cairnsman]

If they debut White this week then I will run nude from Seaford to Moorabbin.

Bloody stupid if they put him in this week against a team that needs to tear us apart up at the SCG...think about it.

[LTN16]

If they debut White this week then I will run nude from Seaford to Moorabbin.

Bloody stupid if they put him in this week against a team that needs to tear us apart up at the SCG...think about it.

I agree. Tell him if he puts in another good performance at sandy this week that he'll be making his debut next week against Richmond.

[plugger66]

If they debut White this week then I will run nude from Seaford to Moorabbin.

Bloody stupid if they put him in this week against a team that needs to tear us apart up at the SCG...think about it.

I agree. Tell him if he puts in another good performance at sandy this week that he'll be making his debut next week against Richmond.

Reckon the Tigers are going OK also. If he isnt injured and form is good enough and there is a spot then he plays. Seems he ticks all 3 this week. Doesnt matter who we play. Whay if it rains against the tigers?

[Cairnsman]

If they debut White this week then I will run nude from Seaford to Moorabbin.

Bloody stupid if they put him in this week against a team that needs to tear us apart up at the SCG...think about it.

I agree. Tell him if he puts in another good performance at sandy this week that he'll be making his debut next week against Richmond.

Reckon the Tigers are going OK also. If he isnt injured and form is good enough and there is a spot then he plays. Seems he ticks all 3 this week. Doesnt matter who we play. Whay if it rains against the tigers?

Better to be beaten by the conditions than to be beat up by a team just raring to chew us up and spit us out. The Swans will go for our jugular this week.

[plugger66]

If they debut White this week then I will run nude from Seaford to Moorabbin.

Bloody stupid if they put him in this week against a team that needs to tear us apart up at the SCG...think about it.

I agree. Tell him if he puts in another good performance at sandy this week that he'll be making his debut next week against Richmond.

Reckon the Tigers are going OK also. If he isnt injured and form is good enough and there is a spot then he plays. Seems he ticks all 3 this week. Doesnt matter who we play. Whay if it rains against the tigers?

Better to be beaten by the conditions than to be beat up by a team just raring to chew us up and spit us out. The Swans will go for our jugular this week.

And if the Tigers win this week so will they. You shouldnt pick a player based on the opposition. If he played against Freo he would have got many more oppotunities that anyone would have thought beforehand.

[whiskers3614]

Why don't we give one of the reserve ruckmen a go too?
Couldn't do a lot less than Longer.

[Cairnsman]

If they debut White this week then I will run nude from Seaford to Moorabbin.

Bloody stupid if they put him in this week against a team that needs to tear us apart up at the SCG...think about it.

I agree. Tell him if he puts in another good performance at sandy this week that he'll be making his debut next week against Richmond.

Reckon the Tigers are going OK also. If he isnt injured and form is good enough and there is a spot then he plays. Seems he ticks all 3 this week. Doesnt matter who we play. Whay if it rains against the tigers?

Better to be beaten by the conditions than to be beat up by a team just raring to chew us up and spit us out. The Swans will go for our jugular this week.

And if the Tigers win this week so will they. You shouldnt pick a player based on the opposition. If he played against Freo he would have got many more oppotunities that anyone would have thought beforehand.

Hindsight call on the Freo game. Pretty sure the good clubs take into consideration the opposition and game circumstances when selecting a player for his debut.