Saints join race for Murdoch - ex Cat

[Bowey Boy]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-11-01/a ... -for-speed

ST KILDA has emerged as a new bidder to claim former Geelong speedster Jordan Murdoch in the Delisted Free Agency Period.......

[shrodes]

Brother of Brodie isn't he?

[Selhurst Saint]

No thanks

[stevie]

If he brings his buddies BA, Hannibal and Face then we have a chance to become a real A team

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

Kid can run, is quick and get the footy, but his disposal isn't that flash and is inconsistent.

Townsend or Lonergan might be better options.

[spert]

Who would he push out of the Geelong midfield...Ablett, Danger, Selwood? Until one of those three pull the plug, nobody will get that gig.

[DJ Higgins]

Geelong is a hard midfield to crack into but that fact they don't want him as a depth player worries me. I'll pass as we don't want another average player. And lets be honest if their coaches couldn't get him up to speed we have no chance

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

He's better and had a far better career than Minchington. Going on that logic and as several supporters are unhappy Minchington has been delisted, we should take Murdoch as a replacement.

[samuraisaint]

Brother of Brodie isn't he?

Yep.

[Cairnsman]

Depth in the midefiled. We need it.

Can't see anything else other than midfielders selected in the draft.

[silverhalo]

Depth in the midefiled. We need it.

Can't see anything else other than midfielders selected in the draft.

Apart from our first selection, Max King. You could almost classify him as a mid actually given that he is so mobile for a big man

[Myron Gaines]

Wasted list spot, why bother? He’ll take games away from younger players that need afl senior experience & delay their development.

[oldie60]

106 games in six years at a club that has been one of the mainstays of the competition, don't think would be such a bad pick up. Nice size with strong body could help whilst some of the younger blokes build.

[mad saint guy]

Another Colm Begley/Shane Birss/Dean Polo/Koby Stevens. Do not want

[spert]

Wasted list spot, why bother? He’ll take games away from younger players that need afl senior experience & delay their development.

Need a bit of insurance- not a lot of the younger guys are going to make it- a few will, but can't totally go down the youth path.

[Joffa Burns]

He's better and had a far better career than Minchington. Going on that logic and as several supporters are unhappy Minchington has been delisted, we should take Murdoch as a replacement.

Agree with that, but he’s also had a far superior career that Kent. Using your logic we should grab him and dump Kent before he starts.

Actually no for me, he’s as hard at the footy as Scrimshaw, no thanks.

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

Murdoch may have been more sucessful than Kent so far, but Kent has far more upside.

[SaintPav]

Another Colm Begley/Shane Birss/Dean Polo/Koby Stevens. Do not want

This is a little disrespectful to Koby Stevens.

Koby was a good player.

[guitars4]

Murdoch may have been more sucessful than Kent so far, but Kent has far more upside.

Agree with you Ted if Kent can get his injury problems under control he will be very handy but he hasn't been able to do that at Melbourne lets hope he is not our next Nathan Freeman

[mad saint guy]

Another Colm Begley/Shane Birss/Dean Polo/Koby Stevens. Do not want

This is a little disrespectful to Koby Stevens.

Koby was a good player.

His best was good but never played at his best consistently

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

I think Murdoch would be ok for us and he's a pretty good footballer, but he's just another victim of the list turnover process of any club.

[degruch]

Another Colm Begley/Shane Birss/Dean Polo/Koby Stevens. Do not want

This is a little disrespectful to Koby Stevens.

Koby was a good player.

Shane Birss wasn't too bad either, obviously had a falling out with Lyon.

Anyways...Murdoch...inconsistent, except normally did quite well against us, I hope we're not falling victim to Stockholm Syndrome!

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

Is weighing up between Saints and Suns atm. We have offered him a contract though, along with Suns.

[Joffa Burns]

Murdoch may have been more sucessful than Kent so far, but Kent has far more upside.

Based on what Teddysainter?
Have you even seen Kent play?
How does Kent have more upside.

[Joffa Burns]

Is weighing up between Saints and Suns atm. We have offered him a contract though, along with Suns.

On your record I’ll back him going to a club not listed above