Could I be PM'd the latest on this info??? Easten???

Cheers.

We would SMASH the absolute s*** out of them.

n1ck wrote:Im interested to know how hes 'undersized' too..

Charman is a giant.

You only need to see him standing next to Gehrig to see how big he is.

197cm. But gives nothing away in the RUCK.

McQualter will STAR. No doubt. Is it a coincidence that we have been a strong team playing finals with players like Lenny Hayes, Nick Dal Santo, Luke Ball & Robert Harvey??? Always a lot harder to crack into a STRONG midfield. I find that hard to see when he isnt even a star at the Scorps in am...

I am of the view that you NEVER, EVER trade away a first round draft pick. Especially not for a ruckman who is injury prone. Why would St Kilda want another injury prone player? Well that is a very naive view. Never ever? Whatever. Thats a very simplistic viewpoint to have. And he's not injury pron...

There's no denying that a RUCKMAN IS THE DIFFERENCE between St Kilda winning a premiership and just finsihing around the mark (ie 3rd, 4th and 8th). Eevryone wants extra midfielders.....The root cause of the problem is the lack of talented ruckman at the club. Neither you or I can prove that and it...

Here's a chance for the AFL to spite up by giving him a 1 week suspension.

McQualter will STAR. No doubt. Is it a coincidence that we have been a strong team playing finals with players like Lenny Hayes, Nick Dal Santo, Luke Ball & Robert Harvey??? Always a lot harder to crack into a STRONG midfield. I find that hard to see when he isnt even a star at the Scorps in am...

And in other breaking news.


I DONT rate Seaby AT ALL.

We beat the Eagles in the clearances. Poor skill-level and missed chances at goal cost us the game. Not Dean Cox. OWTS....Like so many others you seriously undervalue the worth of a quality ruckman. Have a look at all the media personalitys that publicly state they dont rate ruckman.....THEY ARE AL...

Charman's stats are about the same as Kosi's. He is over-rated and his value is over-inflated. Plus he is very injury-prone, and averages 14 games per season over the past 4 years. So we would be throwing away a potential 250-game classy midifielder for an under-sized 26-year old ruckman who is inj...

McQualter will STAR. No doubt.


Is it a coincidence that we have been a strong team playing finals with players like Lenny Hayes, Nick Dal Santo, Luke Ball & Robert Harvey???


Always a lot harder to crack into a STRONG midfield.

Do we need a 'par' ruckman that badly? I'd give a fair bit for Lade or Cox, but they can keep the rest. Charman is a STAR...He has carried and grown as the number one ruckman in Brisbane for a while. He is just about past that 'maturing' stage and will only get better and better. This is the type o...

Too bad you read the previous, but that's life! Thats a bit better dude....Im not having pot shot at anyone. AND Im not doubting the effort of those supporters that created these banners personally. Im just saying that it dosnt convey the RIGHT image. Surely with the loss it puts it more into persp...

Otiman wrote:I'd rather miss the 8 than barrack for Collingwood to win next week.

The thought of doing so just makes me ill.

Who else is in the same boat as me?

Comon dude, a bit of perspective PLEASE.


We can barrack for Collingwood NOW....and beat the s*** out of them in the finals...


Its WIN WIN.

And im not blaming anyone for the loss. How did you come up with that? The same way you decided it was a disgrace, which was your opinion and of no importance! I don't cry about much but if someone gets in my face you'll want to be a brave man to keep it up! What did you do about the whole Baker th...

I think Sam Lane likes him.

Now crawl into MY hole? Its comments like that, that destroy thequality of focused FOOTBALL discussion on this forum. Focused?? Focused on what? Blaming everyone and anything for the loss last night?? I'll apologise for the 'hole' comment, but I think if supporters want to show a bit of colour abou...

Anyone bolt back into the ground when you found out that we could still snatch the game?? Feel a little foolish when you found out we were one decent clearance and a mark inside 50 away from snatching the game?? Personally I would have been proud to feel part of a very special club if we'd got up. ...

Because your club is too broke to 1. identify enough talent to make an informed choice 2. properly develop the player once he gets to the club This Priddis you watched last night is so far ahead of where he was in 2005 (the year he was rookie listed) that its ridiculous to think that its just luck ...

Thats a bulls*** post from someone that has obviously not played the game.... Ferguson was extremely good tonight in the conditions he was forced into. It was was practically his first game. Against good opposition and under a midfield that provided so much delivery out of the centre. He was also f...

So Spinner, you reckon showing our angst was wrong cos it wasnt the game at hand?? Well..maybe we were dirty that for the second year running, a dodgy treibunal decision has cost us our premier tagger against the comp's premier midfield Reckon that if we'd had Bakes to swing onto Cousins after 1/2 ...

We should have a look at Boyd from the doggies, wonder if we could interest them with a Barry Brooks, or dare i say it, Fergus Watts or Jarryd Allen. As the Dogs have been criticised in the last week or so with their "topping up" in the last year or two, I don't think they'd go for anyone...

Typical Typical ST KILDA..... The banners last night were a disgrace. Any mid-week episode is always going break our concentration because we are weak minded. The AFL is a disgrace and I could easily get nasty on you for your comments but I think you've sadly missed the entire point of the banners!...

n1ck wrote:We should have a look at Boyd from the doggies, wonder if we could interest them with a Barry Brooks, or dare i say it, Fergus Watts or Jarryd Allen.

Plus draft picks of course.

he would be the cheapest out of the best fullbacks IMO.

Boyd????

Isnt he a midfielder????