https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vjARA6_GSm8 Thanks for the video JB. I love how the description says he ‘fits the prototype of the modern midfielder’ yet he has barely played in the middle since. The coaching staff should have developed him into a weapon. I really want to see him have a crack under...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vjARA6_GSm8 Thanks for the video JB. I love how the description says he ‘fits the prototype of the modern midfielder’ yet he has barely played in the middle since. The coaching staff should have developed him into a weapon. I really want to see him have a crack under...

Goddard has the turning circle of the Queen Mary hence deployed as a quarter back If he was so good why was he used in that role and not in the “guts” He was generally a good ball user but his possessions were usually accrued in the spare quarter back role including by demanding the ball as the fre...

In - Pick 10, Future 4th Round Out - Pick 12, Pick 18, Future 3rd Round - Effectively Pick 18 for Howard - Ryder a swap of 3rd and 4th round picks - Slight upgrade from 12 to 10 I sure to hell hope Howard is worth Pick 18.... Me too but I believe he has something given the popularity. Hes tall, rel...

Good trade - so we've got 2 players and still have pick 10 plus some 3rd/4th round exchanges - not sure why PA did this deal?? They did suggest Howard look around and he was obviously popular. His bidding pick value also increased with Port wanting 2 round 1 picks. I can only assume they are lookin...

You missed the point. It was zilch, or pick 58. We took 58. Good deal. Precisely, there's no point in agonising over this trade, Jack was most unlikely to return to anywhere near his best form when at his peak a few years ago. Winning 4 B&Fs at St Kilda has to be seen in context because not onc...

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Tue 15 Oct 2019 8:42pm Saints should tell the Pussies to shove their pick up their clacker. Steven then can make a decision to play or give it up.

If they did this I don't think Geelong would batter an eyelid and say OK you keep him and manage/deal with the situation.

Why should we have to ‘cop it’? He’s a contracted player 58 for a four time b&f is a disgrace! Geelongs question might be Why should we have to cop it. If Geelong rate Jack in terms of risk factors like consequence and frequency of issues, they may think all the potential value of Jack on the p...

The Cats can go to hell. They're taking advantage of the situation. In my view, they're using Steven's mental health issues to screw us over with a total lack of respect for both our club and our player. By offering us pick 57 they're sending the message that Steven is almost worthless. They know t...

I'm getting a bit jack of this now, if Freo keeps making these unreasonable demands, as much as I'd love to have Hill, I'd be really satisfied to get the other 4 as they do address a number of our needs, keep pick 12 for the draft and target a speedy mid. https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/geel...

Channel Seven saying he’s likely to come to us. Also saying Cats will get Steven for “almost nothing” Ch7 can go and get fuckedz. channel 7 and Fox seem to I will happen. Fox thinks Geelongs list manager is just posturing and Jack will be traded for either 36 or 37 from the Kelly trade. Goddard (tr...

We need class ball users- especially by foot and Butler has that. Ratt's comment about ball butchers later in the season pointed to the fact that he probably wants to weed out the butchers and bring in the class. and so we should. It should have happened years ago as its cost us a lot in so many wa...

Wowza! Probably bad news for Brown. What’s he worth? Yep. Bad news for Brown who has been a warrior for the Saints. At the moment, we have nothing to trade except a player. Maybe the club will more than likely see how the Bruce and Steven trades play out hoping to get a pick they can on pass to Por...

st.byron wrote: ↑Wed 09 Oct 2019 9:58pm

B.M wrote: ↑Wed 09 Oct 2019 9:40pm I think Jake has a Spider Eviritt type attitude. Can play, huge natural talent, but has some character flaws, is a bit lazy, and is a bit selfish.

Yep he also gives me that impression.

Agree mostly but he doesn't have that laconic side to his game that Spider had.

FYI. Josh was not one of the more popular members of the playing group. I’m sorry I’m not going to further expand on that but just trying to give you some reason for his movement. With respect and I understand that you have some “ credibility “ on this site , but this post is disgraceful What you h...

FYI. Josh was not one of the more popular members of the playing group. I’m sorry I’m not going to further expand on that but just trying to give you some reason for his movement. With respect and I understand that you have some “ credibility “ on this site , but this post is disgraceful What you h...

If by chance the Dogs give up that first rounder for Brucey and another pick/player, then it could happen this year. Would probably really need decent steak knives to get it across the line. 13 & Acres for Hill. 6 & (insert player here) for King. Too optimistic. Freo wont accept that. We wo...

Saint 58 wrote: ↑Fri 04 Oct 2019 2:27pm I had a look on the Cats site

One poster was good saying that we wanted fair value for a good player that they want
The rest of them, FMD what a bunch of arrogant dickheads
I had to check to make sure I wasn't on the Blues site !!

Amazing. Steven was 8th in the Brownlow just one year ago (2018). So, just one back - he was a top 10 AFL player. How can he be traded for anything less than a first round selection, just one year later? When fit again (acknowledging issues in 2019), he is a STAR. Yep ahead of Dangerfield and 1 beh...

B.M wrote: ↑Wed 02 Oct 2019 3:15pm Didn’t Jack finish top 10 in the Brownlow 2 seasons ago?

In a bottom side?

Ross was 24th with 14 votes. Jack had 11 votes (couldn't find s total vote tally list).

DJ Higgins wrote: ↑Wed 02 Oct 2019 2:42pm Paper says that we won't release him for anything less than a pick in the twenties. That is what I like to here but cats don't have a pick in the twenties

Might do after Kelly move.

I would not consider releasing Acres under any circumstances McKenzie, Webster or our other defensive flankers now surpassed by Clark and Coffield is an entirely different story Acres can impact where we need impact Hill and Ryder address 2 deficiencies - outside pace, daring and skill and that we ...

I listened to Wells, he's clever, not committing to anything and painting St Kilda as a "good club" who will look after him. Why should Wells commit? No need when he can try to box St Kilda in by choosing to look after Jack's health or get the best deal, i.e. his value. Worst case, Steven...

Steven is threatening to retire if he doesn’t get traded to the Cats, we should just let him f****** retire if he’s going to start playing those games!!! f*** HIM That sort of comment wont go down well at the Cattery. It increases the risk associated with the player and how that might look as desta...

52, Constable, a big $ savinh and move on. He has played his best football and gave all he had. He will cop a big pay cut and get what he wants. Great deal of it happens. I wish him well. I love looking at the commentary in media and various forums at this time of year but I really don't have any i...