talking of ex players i was listening to the local radio station and they were talking to Heath Black who basically said coming to st kilda was the worst thing he ever did :shock: and he hoped Chris Judd wasnt making the same mistake ... i hated Blacky for leaving us to go back to freo but now i ha...

some of you guys are just lovely, well balanced human beings...

certainly something worth getting annoyed about

A greater certainty in football there is not. I will call this one right now and book mark it. Judd is used to the absolute best and there is no way that this intelligent young man who is concerned RE OP is going to come to a club that... - Hasn't been able to manage Luke Balls OP over 2-3 years - H...

fonz_#15 wrote:
it could never have been him since he had only een on the list 1 year and draftees must play at least 2

that just means they'd have to have paid out his contract

This trade is simply too high risk

you'd have to give up so much for what you might get back. Personally, I don't like it.

Prismal, Haselby and Pettifer r safer targets

the bottom line is that he would add depth to our midfield rotation...

that's one more classy player to take the heat off Dal, Monty etc and 1 more classy player to make Birss and Armitage etc earn their spot into the team...

I'd give up a second rounder for him + maybe a GOP like mini

Do u guys r'ber when TS40 got the axe, it was rumoured that the day b4 the deadline that 1 more Saint may cop it too... we all thought that that mysterious Saint may have been Raph Clarke but the rumour mill has it that was Sweeney that may have gone due to his attitude. He did make a bit of a late ...

have to bear in mind that a detailed report of everything they had in mind would never have been on the agenda for today

i'm sure we'll hear about what they have issues with and what's on their agenda in the coming weeks

would love to see AF get the chop... not impressed with this man at all

Lets see

Mark Seaby
Paul Haselby
Kayne Petteifer

+ a few kids in the draft with no major player losses - plugs a few holes in our list

make it happen boys

i reckon i must be the only forumite that appreciates the fact that Everite stuck with us from 1999-02 when other clubs like the pies were throwing big $$$ to lure him over

he showed us a bit of loyalty

All you need is 1 new player to step up

a stable starting 22

a little bit of luck

and you're a shoe'in for the premiership

Ppl seem to forget that Watts broke his leg like twice last year and virtually missed the entire season and then some... surely you have to expect that this would slolw down his development +++... he threw together a reasonable come back season in the reserves and is only now ready to take take his ...

Not nearly good enough for the price he would demand

riccardo wrote:Surprised about McLaren, they were extatic to get him only a few years ago, beat a few clubs for him including our own, I think?

Would we give him a go, considering we need a ruckman?

This is a guy who has been replaced by Ackland

how old is he?

C'mon Justin Plapp wasn't too bad. Sure he didn't make it but he played some good games for us and certainly does not deserve to be in the worst of category... I remember this one game V Port, I think it was after GT took over from MB, Port were in control and they just kept bombing it forward and P...

he wasn't as bad as ppl make out... played a few serviceable games

how about Will Minson?

don't need him

can't see where he would fit; would have to take a spot infornt of Milne, X, Fiora, Gilbert...

nope

S.Milne - Maybe time to go. Reasonable 30 goal return, however his value could pull together a fair trade for the right player e.g Milne for Seaby? Straight swap for mine. :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: I don't like that, maybe get them to throw in Judd just to even that trade up

I like him more in the back half...

not only is he a good defensive player but he forces his opponent up the ground to be accountable...

the kind of player who could drift down and bang a goal from 50 out

Just thought I'd have a little look at some of the ex-saints that have been running around recently and the trades we got for them... Trent Knobel: He left for nothing and his career nose dived accordingly. His form with us probably better than any of our current ruckman to date. Pbly would have bee...

It appeared that our core list peaked from about 2004-06 In those years Port, Bris, Adel, Wce and Syd to a lesser degree always looked a bit like the unstoppable jaggurnuat teams. We all felt that once the finals started it would be extremely tough to beat any of these teams interstate... This year,...

OUT
Thompson
Gehrig
Raymond
Sweeney
Brooks
Gwilt
Voss
Doc

Demote
Wall

Promote
Geary

Ferguson and McQualter saved by the skin of their teeth simply because of the mass exodus and the fact that there are no queries over their training and work ethics