If we apply the same standards by which we normally judge raph clarke's performances..... Mini shouldn't get dropped. After all, he had a great 2009... Remember?

Don't know what the fascination with Raph Clarke is, he's ordinary to say the least and certainly wouldn't make any other team list. His supporters constantly refer to the one or two games that he saved the team or had a blinder.... it's in the past, let it go.

Mini was outstanding this year!

How quickly is his performance this year written off by some people???

Thank God RL is running the team...

Brownlow medal: Lenny MVP trophie: Riewoldt St Kilda players to make AA: Roo, Lenny, Dal, BJ Top 4: Saints, Crows, Hawks, Bulldogs Grand final teams: Saints v Crows Grand final winner: Saints Norm smith winner: Riewoldt Wooden spooner: Carlton Player to explode: Gwilt Player to implode: Raphael St K...

We don't need him, his time has passed.... he wasn't even in our 22 when he did his knee this time!

Just kicking for goal screwed us, we've missed easy ones all year and we paid the price today...

I passed out... C'mon boys!!!!

Let's not worry about it people!! Every premiership team in history has had a couple of passengers!! Personally I'd prefer Gwilt in for Raph, at least Gwilt can kick a goal.

Probably already mentioned, but there's a framed saints jumper on the wall in his new movie "Funny People"....

Goal kicking is what lets Kosi and Roo down, they have missed some shockers. It's one aspect of the game they need to work on. My heart's always in my mouth when either one of these two are lining up anywhere past 20 metres...

Andrew 'Mini' McQualter. He was on the scrap heap not so long ago, now look at him. Just needs to get that porno moustache back in time for the GF.

You guys missed what Norwood meant... He is blind and had to listen to the game on the wireless. Hang in there mate.

5. Schneider
4. Montagna
3. McQualter
2. Riewoldt
1. Goddard

5 Ray
4 Reiwoldt
3 Hayes
2 Milne
1 McQualter

Love the 'comeback kid's' year so far... Has come back from the brink of no-AFL career, well done RL in keeping the faith in him. Now cover yourself in glory son and win us a flag!

Liked Mini ever since I saw him running around with that porn mo a few years back...

Well done son! Now grow back the mo!

At least you don't have to wait until 11.59pm to watch the f***ing game on channel 7 here in Brisbane....

5-Kosi
4-Hayes
3-McQualter
2-Gram
1-Gwilt

Raph and Bakes have to be outs, we've got blokes waiting in the wings that can do better and they should get a couple of games under them before the Cats game...

Spot on Vince, what is this charity minded thinking that some supporters have? "Oh, he needs a few games to get firing..." WTF you're in the top team so you should have been busting a gut at Sandy to get there. There are other players who are chomping at the bit AND don't need "a few ...

BIG MART, that's exactly what I was referring to, good to see that some people can read...

How about Kosi's first shot at goal in first term, he somehow missed to the right, absolute easy shot!!... Really should put them away, Cats will make us pay if we don't nail the gimmes...

I'm assuming this whole thread was a gee up.... Mini is doing fine FFS.

I was at the Carlton vs Freo game and threw up when I saw RH wearing a blues polo and carrying a white board... sickening. Looked like he could still cut it...

Carlton vs Freo was cartainly not a sell-out...