Guess this weeks ins and outs

[plugger66]

In today
Wilkes
Polo
Ray

Final
In Polo

Out
Cripps

[VODM]

You might be right - the Bulldogs have a lot of run through the middle and Polo may be needed to shut down one of them.

[Richter]

IN: Wilkes, Polo, Winmar

Final
IN: No-one
OUT: No-one

Emerg: Cripps

(This is what I would like to happen, but I actually think that what will happen is what Pluggs has suggested, with Newnes as sub)

[stkildathunda]

Aren't we playing Saturday which means no extended squads?

OUT: Newnes
IN: Polo

[jonesy]

I wouldn't have a clue about team selection,I would never have thought Newnes was in line a week ago.

However I am mystified why Sipposs isn't playing? Anyone know the reason? Disciplinary? Would of thought moving forward he was an absolute lock in the 22.
Would like to Ledger get a gig on the ground also,is he not fit enough or something?

[defacto]

I wouldn't have a clue about team selection,I would never have thought Newnes was in line a week ago.

However I am mystified why Sipposs isn't playing? Anyone know the reason? Disciplinary? Would of thought moving forward he was an absolute lock in the 22.
Would like to Ledger get a gig on the ground also,is he not fit enough or something?

i'd say it has to do with structure. playing kozi, roo and stanley means our fwd line is already pretty tall. siposs has a tendency to drift out of the game for long periods of time, which we cant really afford when we already have stanley in there, who also drifts out of the game (albeit alot less). the thing stanley has on his side is he can go into the ruck. siposs could really only go on the wing, but again he drifts out of games.

siposs also was quiet in the last vfl game and suffered a pretty heavy knock to the knee in the game before that. give him time. he'll get his shot, just needs to get some vfl form back first.

atm i think wilkes is ahead of siposs for a recall

[Kernal75]

No change - swap Cripps and Ledger for the sub role. Why change a winning side.

[Dr Spaceman]

Aren't we playing Saturday which means no extended squads?

OUT: Newnes
IN: Polo

Well I'm going on Saturday night so I sure hope we are

And given that, yes it should just be the 22 named tonight

[dragit]

I think polo will come in for cripps, though I would like to see winmar in for cripps personally.

[Dr Spaceman]

I think polo will come in for cripps, though I would like to see winmar in for cripps personally.

Has Winmar been playing for Sandy or has he been injured?

[SainterK]

Swapping of the sub vest, Ledger in the starting 18, Cripps to sub.

Emg Wilkes, Peake, Polo

[citywest]

In today
Wilkes
Polo
Ray

Final
In Polo

Out
Cripps

Polo is s***.

[Dr Spaceman]

In today
Wilkes
Polo
Ray

Final
In Polo

Out
Cripps

Polo is s***.

sub only has three letters

[Cairnsman]

In

Ray
Polo

Out

Milne
Cripps

[Ralphy]

Milne wont be dropped.

[Thinline]

Milne will kick 4. Match ups are well in his favour this week.

Cripps to the sub slot, Ledger to the starting side.

Like others I reckon Polo may come in to muscle a WB's running type, possibly for young Newnes.

[clarky449]

In today? Final team? As alluded to above. We are playing on Saturday, are we not? Or am i missing something.

I dont think their will be a change.

[Sobraz]

In reference to Siposs above, I imagine that as BigMart alluded to in another thread, he is being groomed as a more utility type player, perhaps that can run through the middle, and even push back, and use his absolutely elite kicking skills as entry into the F50... Not just as a finisher...

Add a a few string to his bow... Best way to do this is throw him around in the VFL for a few weeks, then let him step it up in the 1's... I guess if he has a few solid hit outs in the VFL in the next fortnight, he'll be in... And to stay...

My guess for this weeks teams...

In: Polo, Out: Newnes. Cripps to sub.

[Richter]

Got to say it but with Milera stepping up and Schneider to come back atm there isn't a spot available for Sippos. He'll need to knock loudly on the door via the VFL and one of the current crop to have a form slump. Having said that a good selection dilemma to be having!

[Dave McNamara]

I'm happy to go with the wisdom of the Kernal, OK and Clarkey. No change - except of the sub.

[AnythingsPossibleSaints]

How could it be Thursday already?

[plugger66]

How could it be Thursday already?

Because yesterday was Wednesday.

[MCG-Unit]

If no injuries:
In Polo (received a coaches vote last time he played - need to lock down some of those WB small/med fwds and mids)
Out Newnes or Cripps

Ledger plays
Sub Cripps or Newnes, whoever stays in

Emg: Cripps or Newnes, Wilkes, Ray

[The Redeemer]

Got to say it but with Milera stepping up and Schneider to come back atm there isn't a spot available for Sippos. He'll need to knock loudly on the door via the VFL and one of the current crop to have a form slump. Having said that a good selection dilemma to be having!

A team can never have too many really good kickers though so a spot would be found for Siposs. If he is being groomed as a utlity/swingman/generally awesome player type role then should he not be able to fit in anywhere on the ground?

[Spinner]

OUT: Cripps

IN: Polo



Although I want Cripps in!