Time for some positive stuff. B&F winners

plugger66 · Post: # 1010061Post **plugger66** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 7:59pm

1 Lenny
2 BJ
3 Joey
4 Milne
5 Gilbert
6 Gwilt
7 Fisher
8 Dal
9 Schneider
10 Ray

saint66au · Post: # 1010064Post **saint66au** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 8:01pm

Reckon that will be pretty close. BJ not without a chance though

saintbrat · Post: # 1010068Post **saintbrat** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 8:03pm

a tie

although if close when it comes to finals BJmay sneak a head on the second G/F

I Love Peter Kiel · Mon 04 Oct 2010 8:03pm

When is it?

#1GILL · Post: # 1010070Post **#1GILL** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 8:03pm

1 BJ
2 Lenny

Daylight

3 Joey
4 Fisher
5 Gilbert
6 Gwilt
7 Blake
8 Schneider
9 Milne
10 Dal Santo

saintbrat · Post: # 1010071Post **saintbrat** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 8:03pm

Wednesday

SainterK · Post: # 1010077Post **SainterK** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 8:06pm

Top 5

BJ
Lenny
Joey
Milne
Gwilt

dcstkfc · Post: # 1010139Post **dcstkfc** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 8:38pm

SainterK wrote:Top 5

BJ
Lenny
Joey
Milne
Gwilt

Milney won't poll that well, his tackling wasn't up to it this year.

BJ
Lenny
Joey
Chips
Gilbo
Jimmy
The Blake
Dal
Milney
Schneids

clarky449 · Post: # 1010143Post **clarky449** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 8:42pm

1. BJ
2. Hayes
3. Joey
4. Milne

#1GILL · Post: # 1010185Post **#1GILL** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 9:13pm

dcstkfc wrote:
SainterK wrote:Top 5

BJ
Lenny
Joey
Milne
Gwilt
Milney won't poll that well, his tackling wasn't up to it this year.

BJ
Lenny
Joey
Chips
Gilbo
Jimmy
The Blake
Dal
Milney
Schneids

Almost exactly the same as my list...Great minds think alike

Mr Magic · Post: # 1010218Post **Mr Magic** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 9:28pm

So everybody thinks Milne will be a Top 10 finish in the B&F and yet there are quite a number of posters demanding he lost his place in the team?

Tom_Sainter · Mon 04 Oct 2010 9:48pm

1. BJ
2. Lenny
3. Gwilt
4. Joey
5. Chips
6. Gilbert
7. Schneider
8. Milne
9. Blake
10. Dal

Enrico_Misso · Mon 04 Oct 2010 9:53pm

Mr Magic wrote:So everybody thinks Milne will be a Top 10 finish in the B&F and yet there are quite a number of posters demanding he lost his place in the team?

The issue with Milne has never been his ability to perform in Home games.

This year he cranked things up and did well interstate.
And in Week 1 and Week 3 of the finals.

But his form in the GF????????

Did enough in the Tie (and came within a bounce of immortality).
But Saturday was a dismal dismal dismal fail (please don't count those two junktime goals). One kick to 3/4 time.

Tom_Sainter · Mon 04 Oct 2010 9:59pm

Enrico_Misso wrote:
Mr Magic wrote:So everybody thinks Milne will be a Top 10 finish in the B&F and yet there are quite a number of posters demanding he lost his place in the team?
The issue with Milne has never been his ability to perform in Home games.

This year he cranked things up and did well interstate.
And in Week 1 and Week 3 of the finals.

But his form in the GF????????

Did enough in the Tie (and came within a bounce of immortality).
But Saturday was a dismal dismal dismal fail (please don't count those two junktime goals). One kick to 3/4 time.

Milney had a lot of mates in the 2nd GF. I think he did enough in the finals to dispell the inuendo about his big game ability. Never easy being a small forward in a high pressure game like saturday.

Mr Magic · Post: # 1010267Post **Mr Magic** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 9:59pm

Enrico_Misso wrote:
Mr Magic wrote:So everybody thinks Milne will be a Top 10 finish in the B&F and yet there are quite a number of posters demanding he lost his place in the team?
The issue with Milne has never been his ability to perform in Home games.

This year he cranked things up and did well interstate.
And in Week 1 and Week 3 of the finals.

But his form in the GF????????

Did enough in the Tie (and came within a bounce of immortality).
But Saturday was a dismal dismal dismal fail (please don't count those two junktime goals). One kick to 3/4 time.

It's pretty hard to do much if the footy doesn't get to you.

I just think he's an easy scapegoat, adn deserves more credit for standing up this year (and many other seasons).
Statistically not many better small forwrds in the history of the game.

saintbrat · Mon 04 Oct 2010 10:07pm

any possibles for the Other two awards that have been given in recent years

Most Promising New Player: (2009 Zac Dawson )
Robert Harvey Most Professional Player: ( 2009 Clint Jones )

Bernard Shakey · Mon 04 Oct 2010 10:10pm

saintbrat wrote:any possibles for the Other two awards that have been given in recent years

Most Promising New Player: (2009 Zac Dawson )
Robert Harvey Most Professional Player: ( 2009 Clint Jones )

No.9 for both?

Enrico_Misso · Mon 04 Oct 2010 10:10pm

I've been to a few B&Fs and usually the atmosphere is pretty good.

But I am worried this week will be like a funeral.

All the supporters I know (including me) are feeling nothing but deep deep despair - still coming to grips with our wretched luck last week and our lame capitulation this week combined with the feeling that ever so slowly our window is closing.

I expect it will be a very subdued night?

Mr Magic · Post: # 1010287Post **Mr Magic** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 10:12pm

saintbrat wrote:any possibles for the Other two awards that have been given in recent years

Most Promising New Player: (2009 Zac Dawson )
Robert Harvey Most Professional Player: ( 2009 Clint Jones )

Was Brett Peake the only new player to get a game?
We can't give it to Lovett - he barely trained with us!

#1GILL · Post: # 1010293Post **#1GILL** » Mon 04 Oct 2010 10:25pm

Mr Magic wrote:
saintbrat wrote:any possibles for the Other two awards that have been given in recent years

Most Promising New Player: (2009 Zac Dawson )
Robert Harvey Most Professional Player: ( 2009 Clint Jones )
Was Brett Peake the only new player to get a game?
We can't give it to Lovett - he barely trained with us!

Tommy boy

plugger66 · Post: # 1010465Post **plugger66** » Tue 05 Oct 2010 7:31am

#1GILL wrote:
Mr Magic wrote:
saintbrat wrote:any possibles for the Other two awards that have been given in recent years

Most Promising New Player: (2009 Zac Dawson )
Robert Harvey Most Professional Player: ( 2009 Clint Jones )
Was Brett Peake the only new player to get a game?
We can't give it to Lovett - he barely trained with us!
Tommy boy

Heyney.

Mr Magic · Post: # 1010472Post **Mr Magic** » Tue 05 Oct 2010 7:55am

plugger66 wrote:
#1GILL wrote:
Mr Magic wrote:
saintbrat wrote:any possibles for the Other two awards that have been given in recent years

Most Promising New Player: (2009 Zac Dawson )
Robert Harvey Most Professional Player: ( 2009 Clint Jones )
Was Brett Peake the only new player to get a game?
We can't give it to Lovett - he barely trained with us!
Tommy boy
Heyney.

DOn't you have to be a first year player at the Club to win that award?
Heyne was drafted the same year as Lynch and Stanley.

Stephen Theodore · Tue 05 Oct 2010 8:23am

1. B.J
2. Lenny
3. Gwilt
4. Montagna
5. Schnieder

Eastern · Post: # 1010520Post **Eastern** » Tue 05 Oct 2010 9:35am

saintbrat wrote:any possibles for the Other two awards that have been given in recent years

Most Promising New Player: (2009 Zac Dawson )
Robert Harvey Most Professional Player: ( 2009 Clint Jones )

Most Promising New player is a difficult one: I believe Brett Peake is too old to get it. Maybe Rhys Stanley

From what I have read, the Robert Harvey Most Professional Player Award would be an extremely difficult 3-Way split: Lenny Hayes, Brendon Goddard or Nick Riewoldt !!

older saint · Tue 05 Oct 2010 10:56am

B&F always interesting as voted by coaches with ranking out of 10 for all players.

At a guess I would think

BJ
Monty
Hayes
Milne
Gilbert

Remember over the whole year not just finals, hence Milne very good when Roo out and Gwilt solid but spectacular in finals.

Most promising new player - Peae
Most Professiona Player - Roo