We have a lot of passengers on our list. Some of those are a product of the Pelican era of multiple players for picks but I think it's a defining year for the following players;

Tom Lee
Tom Curren
Darren Minchington
Nathan Wright
Luke Delaney
Lewis Pearce
Eli Templeton

Disposal kills us time and again, falls over when trying to tackle. Hard as nails yes but shouldn't be in our best 22. He's the Clint Jones of our defensive unit

Our skills were ordinary at best, no forward structure or method. We might have 4 ruckman on our list but only 1 (Longer) looks like he will make the grade!

Time for a vent.......GO!!

Not big enough to play KPD and simply not good enough at AFL level. Last year of his contract will likely be plying his trade in the WAFL next season. Goddard gets first crack this year with Fisher. Only way Tommy gets a crack is if one of those 2 go down

What happened to Rookie listing Farren Ray? Did he decide that he didn't want to do that and instead chance his arm in the various drafts? Would we pick him up as a Rookie given we already committed to Saunders?

Minchington, Curren, Murdoch, Templeton and Saunders (already rookies) are all on borrowed time IMO. Next year is critical to all of these players as if they don't show something they could well find themselves in the firing line!

Let's just hand back the keys to the AFL. Surely after adding a KPP we desperately need and a top 10 draft pick from 2 years ago and still maintaining a first round selection the AFL will see that were unfit to be in the league!

What a melodramatic, pessimistic bunch of supporters we are! In 8 short hours we have called for the head of Bainea who is widely regarded as one of the best operators in the business. Not to mention sacking the same player most were heralding as the missing link in our goal to goal line. Why don't ...

Big Footy board is awash with speculation that North are into Montagna and Saints are open to the idea of trading him. The story goes he wants one last crack at a premiership and wants to explore the idea of moving clubs.

SEN reported just now that they expect Carlisle will nominate the Blues as his club of choice.

We didn't give Cripps the boot he asked to be traded back to WA. There's a difference between him and Rice

Apparently he has claimed until the Giants started winning earlier this year we had all but managed to get Treloar over the line too. Wish some of his rumours had come off. He was talking about Shiel, but nevertheless I wouldn't put too much (or any) weight on what he says. Makes a lot of claims an...

Apparently he has claimed until the Giants started winning earlier this year we had all but managed to get Treloar over the line too. Wish some of his rumours had come off. He was talking about Shiel, but nevertheless I wouldn't put too much (or any) weight on what he says. Makes a lot of claims an...

Offers a lot more than Shenton IMO. If there's no currency for him during the DFA period then we should rookie him

Holmes really needs a lot more time to develop. Getting taught a ruck lesson by Witts who struggles to get a game for the Pies

Dog Sh*t journalism. Purely an opinion piece with no substance. No way Saints will trade Billings

None had any currency in an open market I guess, but it does beg the question of which players will be shopped around during the trade period?

I'd like to see them re-draft Markworth with a late pick or put him on the rookie list to see if he has anything? Give him another season and get his body right. If he doesn't get through the season then there's nothing lost. In effect we would be swapping Sinclair for Markworth which I'm ok with. A...

On the issue of a priority pick, the real issue is that the AFL has painted themselves into a corner with the FA rules which would see Carltom get pick 1&2 if Keuezer leaves. That would give them access to the best 2 KPP's in the draft and set them on their way for years to come. It's effectivel...

Be bold, be brave and get both Carlisle and Bennell this year. Sell the farm, the house and the cattle Saints and just get it done. How is the issue but let's not let details get in the way of our dreams!!

Essendon need a ruckman, we have 4 at the moment. Would Hickey be another option. Personally I want to keep Hickey but depending on how interested we are in him there may have to be collateral damage. Alternatively a future pick next year might be involved?

Id suggest Hawthorn will have an almight crack, they'll have pick 15-20 and could easily throw in a Suckling type player to get it don. They retire Lake and push on Suckling and suddenly they have a deal that could get it done. If he nominates us great, but I think we are less likely we everyone els...

Surely we had a crack at him as well? Maybe he needs to get another perspective on coaching before he comes back to us, although it annoys me a little bit he chose the GWS

Played pretty much every game for a year and a half then fell out of favour suddenly. Watching Sandringham yesterday he played at Full Fwd and did not look interested. Is he contracted and what do people think about him long term?