our problem was we went in with too many talls

bombers wanted MM Can you show us the source where the Saints were offered anything for Goose during Trade Week? Absolutely nothing discussed on here or in the press about a possible trade and any offer. if you want a source you might as well not be on this forum because most of every thing we talk...

dont get me wrong ,i personally dont think they are great players but we still could have got something 4 them , i personally think that pick 26 would have been good value for ball ,

bombers wanted MM

luke ball and matty maquire gone and nothing to show for them , i'm dissapointed to say the least , could have been handled better imo

i think he could be the medium forward that we need 2 kick goals and we would get him very cheap

do you think they are hoping to pick Maquire up as a mature rookie

i think that he would be considering it , strong ties with the new boys and also with ross the boss from his sydney days, would be a handy pick up

borderbarry wrote:With all the anti-Raph members of this forum I am not so sure the result would have been much different.

get real mate its not only this forum , 90% of saints supporters dont rate him as a player

Russell Morris (HAW) was a gun in the back line easy in the side IMO

ytw wrote:Brent Guerra isn't too bad these days.

not in the same league

IMO i think the club has taken the punt that luke will re-sign back with us because he wont want to play for melbourne and not play finals for the rest of his career in witch they will get him for a cheap price and we also retain our depth

peak will be in the side

So if we have a crap player you think that we should keep him just because we are a loyal club , YOU IDIOT , players come and go we cant keep players just for the sake of being a loyal club, if the players arnt up to it move them on . So you are saying you know more than Ross Lyon? Ever been an AFL...

trade ball and leigh fisher for fev

I question the loyalty of the person who started this thread and several who have replied. Are they really Saint supporters or other club supporters stirring things up? If they claim to be Saint supporters they are not good ones. im a very loyal fan and club member of the saint kilda football club ...

you all think he pretty good well then surly hes worth some thing on the trade table

please trade raph

Trade Ball and Eddy for Burgoyne
Trade Maquire for lovett
Brings pace in to the side

Maybe it was gosainters66?
_________________
Formerly known as ohwhenthesaints



no wasnt me but there is alot of people out there who thinks raph isnt up to it

i would like to see some of the kids played in the early part of next year

let the big mac grow times close to the end kingy

trade goose for fev then put kosi to CHB , i still think kosi played his best year at CHB , i think it was his first year ?

careers

Thinline
Club Player

if you read the heading , MY OPINION , so there was no need for the sarcasim, my comment was made on carrers not just one game