Can't remember when I last saw 22 run out for the saints with no passengers - certainly no obvious ones with no ticket hiding in the corner from the met police - With 3 or 4 'must play' guys coming back and another couple of potentials in the wings the selection panel are going to have to make some ...

I'm on the band wagon - looks the goods - is exactly same height and weight as Scarlett - shows poise and just looks tougher each week -last week he laid a big hip and shoulder on Nic Nat then later on big Q - both of who are built like brick sh*thouses - big smother last night --- never looks fazed -

Maybe he will come back

I saw it and they talked about it (finney) on SEN this morning - the pass was not on - there was a man closing from behind who Roo probably didn't see - Milera should have shot from there and he should have goaled - but plenty of others missed from 40 and under last night -- pretty sure Roo will apo...

He looks like he can jump - is 5 inches taller than Blake and 5 years younger - he may be the man to take up the rucking slack for the next month - maybe he will re discover himself

Wilkes started where he left off the week before - dropped a chest mark while unmanned - he gets dropped and doesn't play - along with the guys who go out with injury - fisher, gwilt, sipposs, ledger, amongst those who can take a place

Blake is always on the list when thinking who can make way for young blokes and guys returning from injury - has been for years - but he just keeps performing - last night was outstanding

Pelchen? who ever masterminded the Milera/Saad deal can take a bow.....

was very poor tonight - still needs to work on his endurance

I think it is time for the club to lodge an official complaint and request the game to be reviewed in terms of umpire performance - Won't help for last night - but may improve some umpiring performances in future St Kilda games...

borderbarry wrote:
In Kosi and Sipposs.

Out. Polo.. Blake.

Yes agree

but add also: out cripps - in ledger

I think there are better options at the moment - he needs to spend some time proving himself with Zebs - I like Sipposs & Ledger before Cripps and Scneids is hopefully back soon...

think wilkes needs to be forward

In light of my last post above - i forgot to mention geary - I saw him play a practice match for Sandy V Frankston a few years back and and thought - he needs to be delisted - was hopeless - he has been very very good this year IMO - so is doing the above role - but doesn't have the kicking skills o...

I have been thinking we need someone in this role - i was thinking yarran, shaw, harbrow mould - all those guys have torn us up at times - pre season was thinking del or maybe as an out of the box milera - who is now doing well up forward - could still possibly take the running half back role - but ...

Has some great skills and looks very composed for a 3 gamer - Even with this great composure he does make some level one errors that you think a bit of experience and the work of the coaching staff will sort out - during what was possibly the best piece of individual flair and skill saints supporter...

I might have missed something on another thread - but what has happened to sipposs??

Jones also has massive heart and is brave - but im not sure I fir himin my 22 - Polo definitely not in my 22

Agree. Why not try Nick down back - Watters will make a name for himself if it comes off

I would be suprised if he is off the list next year - He's 20 yrs old - a year yonger than Stanley - From what I've seen live at Sandy he has pretyy good hand and foot skills and has some pretty good movement in tight spots for a big guy - my only concern would be his pace - someone here has said he...

Keen to hear about the jaw as well - thought it was a hamstring -??

if Armo can learn to stay on his feet more - he will be good

So are they saying Lenny is 100% ??

saint6709 wrote: Still thinking about this one! Simpkin sounds like the man - was concerned about his height but have just noticed he is built pretty well the same as Scarlett (Simpkin 191&91 Scarlett 192&94 ) Simpkin has probably put on a kg or two since this stat _ maybe scarlett has as w...

Still thinking about this one! Simpkin sounds like the man - was concerned about his height but have just noticed he is built pretty well the same as Scarlett (Simpkin 191&91 Scarlett 192&94 ) Simpkin has probably put on a kg or two since this stat _ maybe scarlett has as well but his more l...