Just shows how overrated Dal is by the general public... it really does... Everyone who isnt an avid watchjer of every week still think he's a superstar...

don't compare the two because its apples and oranges But... he actually tries as oposed to raph Stupid is as stupid does. :lol: ouch... but still you know what i meant... Jones puts his body on the line... has always.... and is a GUN player in VFL.... I'm saying to compare them as both awesome VFL ...

you are not basing your assumptions on fact...by the way you are stating things you havent watched him play just looking at the state squad which he didn't make... He is a very solid player will only improve his skills and ability... When did I say I havent wached him play. Have seen him 3 times th...

Silvagni is a gun footballer and should definately be looked at, Max will probably retire at seasons end and here is one bloke who can step up. Saying he can't kick is ridiulous because he hits his targets when he has to. Has the speed to play short and the strangth to play tall. Very quick off the...

you are not basing your assumptions on fact...by the way you are stating things you havent watched him play just looking at the state squad which he didn't make...

He is a very solid player will only improve his skills and ability...

his kicking has been quite good and although it is his weakness he continues to impress so must be promoted If we promote him ahead of Geary - who at least has some sort of future at AFL level - it shows we've got no idea. Of course Jones can play at VFL level. Of course his skills are better at th...

yeh he definately should of made the state squad tho... just because he didnt doesnt mean he didn't deserve it....

I think Goddard can play on Brown If not, play Goddard as FF in lew of Kosi I find this very wasteful of BJ... he is the best kick in the league pin point and this is robbing peter to pay paul... it would be hard for BJ to get 20 kicks in either position and that is vital for our lack of efficiency...

FB's do not need a booming kick or kick like BJ jsut need to stop their man.... it should be the others who should be feeding off them... He is better than our other options for KPP Backs who r who right now??? It's Hudghton, Maguire.... and to an extent Fisher but i believe fisher is wasted in this...

yes but he has tried to atone for his mistakes and i believe is up for it... just needs to adjust he can play and will be an AFL player in my opinion just gotta give him a crack... in the VFL last 2 weeks his kicking has been quite good and although it is his weakness he continues to impress so must...

silvagni is a gun and a key position player only bad thing about him is his kicking is very ordinary but no FF's have really beaten him this year... good player and we should pick him up is only 20 and would be good for depth... he would be in the team right now...

2 BOG's by a mile last 2 weeks... should be a DEFNITE STARTER I am not boing smart but have you seen the last 2 games and if yes who else is up for promotion. Watched the game on tv this week but last week i was there... Well last week was blake played well.... Fiora is a dud.... McEvoy looked alri...

y do we have so many taggers who cant get the ball themselves? Baker, Fisher, Blake, Birss... surely we dont need this many... how r we supposed to win the game yes they limit their players but they get less of it too... Baker is the only decent player out of that bunch

2 BOG's by a mile last 2 weeks... should be a DEFNITE STARTER

:0 forumite now playing for the scorpions who drew the ire of some at cross forum football matches when the opposition found out he was trying out for a VFL team. has only played a couple of games in the reserves so far - but has been found on either the goal kicking or best on list each time After...

it's really heartbreaking....

Armitage - no good and will never be any good - I've too many footballers with his lack of skill over the years persevered with to our detriment and then finally let go. The sooner they act the better. Can't win a contest Birss - did his best but not up to it , can't win a contest. Gardiner C - hop...

how does thius thread even exist? surely he has no positives...except at least he will be delisted at the end of the year great positive

wat a disgrace of a footballer been saying it all year where are the smart asses who were non stop having a go at me about this... still this joke gets a game... no wonder we're rubbish

i'd assume so... at this stage is a definite to play....

disappointed CJ wasn't picked and actually play him on the wing where his pace is damaging and is a ball magnet... The main skill of a wingman is delivery to the forward line. how does he go in that department. i heard he was best on ground last week u can't ignore that His delivery was good on the...

elimination final against melb

and

that hawks game last year was the worst game EVER to watch!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! three goals all up at half time

disappointed CJ wasn't picked and actually play him on the wing where his pace is damaging and is a ball magnet...

thanks saintbrat... 2004 it was i guess not 2003 , Bally though is a worry which is disappointing...If Mini gets a gig i hope he grabs it with both hands