cwrcyn wrote: ↑Sat 16 Jun 2018 6:47am Most of the atrocious decisions early on were driven by Pelchen, but I can see why this decision was made. If Hughes takes over, the we'll be worse off. He's utterly hopeless and I'm staggered we even employed him given his horrible record.

If Hughes takes over we may as well close the doors.

If the club think Trout is a big enough scalp to appease people my good they have contempt for the fans. Giving Richo a two year extension after our insipid end to last season was a horrendous error of judgment. Did I miss the press release where the club suggested this? I believe only one of the a...

Whispers and word about town is that we are front runners to obtain Jack s***. Fits are need for more Jacks on our list. For those of you unfamiliar with Jack s***, he is a half back flanker who may by the twelve year of his career progress to a part time onballer. Comes from a great family, his mum...

Ok so some bristle at comparisons to Richmond's plight in 2016 and thier decission not to sack Hardwick. Collingwood and thier decission not to sack Nathan Buckley in 2017 anyone. Buckley is batting at 53%. https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/cp-nathan-buckley--91 If Richo was anywhere near 53% nob...

I'm flabbergasted. Richo has the worst record of any coach to make 100 games in ALL history. Yes. AFL history. Spot on con, and it will cost him is job. But still has nothing to do with comparing a coach who inherited a grand final team with a guy who inherited a rabble. Personally I would move him...

Not defending Richo, but comparing him to Buckley is rubbish. That is just trying to suite your view, I have judged him three years of pass marks and two fails. I would not have extended his contract but like most things con you are over the top and irrational. His percentage of wins against Buckley...

Buckley inherited a list that made the grand final. Richo inherited a basket case that some thought would not win a game. Buckley went backwards every year other than this, Richo improved in his first few. Winning percentages are great but need to be taken in context to where the team was when you t...

Was watching Paddy closely tonight. He was ignored on the lead 10 times that I counted when he was well clear of Grundy. Most of the kicks to him were in his head, when they did decide to honour his leads. He worked hard and presented , wish the majority of his team mates had worked as hard. Only do...

I think in the paper the other day they had our top 3 indigenous players in our history being Winmar, X Clarke and R Clarke! :shock: Yep I saw that, obviously never heard of Robert Muir or Gilbert McAdam Would have thought it was Winmar, McAdam and then a huge gap to the rest. McAdam was a wonderfu...

Playing the racist card junior....real shitman's act and entirely predictable. Have you contacted the club yet? and what about one of the aboriginals who played with Gwilt....contacted one of them yet? Or Contact Gilbert mcadam, he'd probably knock your block off if he got hold of you...... Like wo...

I think in the paper the other day they had our top 3 indigenous players in our history being Winmar, X Clarke and R Clarke! :shock: Yep I saw that, obviously never heard of Robert Muir or Gilbert McAdam Would have thought it was Winmar, McAdam and then a huge gap to the rest. McAdam was a wonderfu...

Gwilt was not aboriginal but fair to say he was not white. I have no problem with him being on that list. Why dont you ring the club up and ask them about his inclusion, or better still ring up Nicky Winmar or x man and ask if he should be on the list. One of the most offensive posts I have seen in...

Embarrassing , Gwilt is not indigenous mum from PNG and dad from the UK.

My father and I were reserve seat holders at Moorabbin , in the early 1980's the club in their wisdom decided to install some open air corporate boxes behind our seats. This was all okay for every week of the season until Collingwood came to town. Sitting in our seats watching the reserve game , whe...

My father contacted the club after the JLT series and vented his spleen about our constant bombing off the ball to the top of the square . Asked the question what they had spent the summer working on? To the clubs credit he received a reply stating that they had identified this as an issue and that ...

It is their version of the next gen academy so only applicable to indigenous players or players with a parent from a non english speaking background,

[quote=SaintPav post_id=1728435 time=1526645625 user_id=19322] Great consultation on this Simon. Hardly any notification if any at all about the changes. Typical of the way this place is run. [/ Ungrateful , not like you are paying a fee for the service. As someone else suggested if you don't like i...

Well, as a Saints supporter, this only warms the cockles of my heart. NOT. You prefer the hawks got up? Tom McCartin had 3 tackles. Probably more than Paddy has had in his career thus far. Paddy averages the same amount of tackles per game this year as. Membrey and only .1 per game less than Carlis...

Goddard is not and has never been a leaders arsehole. Finger pointer who abuses his teammates , admire what he nearly did in the 2010 grand final but no need for him to be anywhere near our club. Unlike Dal Santo who was forced out BJ was all about the money and personal success, played golf with Ja...

Was clearly moved aside for Lethlean.

I have a family member who deals with him in his current role
And can not speak highly enough of him and what he does.

Believe the game has been moved to Tullamarine due to concerns over the condition of Windy Hill.

Also 2.00pmstary instead of midday.

Drake Huggins wrote:What's the bet we lose him after his initial two year contract?

Must suck being you, most negative person I have ever seen on this forum.

Gee I have seen some absolute rubbish threads over the years but this takes the cake. So Elshuagh who is being paid hundreds of thousands of dollars is going to put his job on the line due to a hatred of the club. Think you will find that the club supported him through health issues a few years bac...

Gee I have seen some absolute rubbish threads over the years but this takes the cake. So Elshuagh who is being paid hundreds of thousands of dollars is going to put his job on the line due to a hatred of the club. Think you will find that the club supported him through health issues a few years back...

Speak to Gary Ayres he rates her highly and I reckon he would know a good coach when he sees one.