Re Carlisle: A bit off topic but I was bored one night last week and watched the replay v the Suns where they thrashed us in Rd 15. I can see why Tommy Lee was delisted. He got destroyed by big Peter Wright - he wont be alone on that because Wright looks like he might destroy a lot of defenders in ...

"In another surprise, St Kilda’s emerging midfield group is ranked seventh, higher than Geelong (eighth), West Coast (ninth), Adelaide (11th) and Hawthorn (12th). St Kilda’s favourable assessment is based on its breadth of established talent, with eight of their nine classified midfielders cons...

I have been inspired by Loris' wonderful story of growing up with the Barrot boys. Thanks Loris. It was fantastic. But I am also famous. Well maybe a tad. Perhaps a microbit. I went to school with Gary Rosewarne, who was the son of Keith Rosewarne, a prodigiously talented St Kilda rover. And to add...

What has what GWS doing with the pick we gifted them got to do with our decision. Milera and Saad? Lee? I love the way people bag Peake, but in reality, his record is in no way worse than the Pelican. Oh the irony of being a hindsight hero while accusing others of the sae! Yeah that's right what ev...

Another Pelchen success! Pick 12 for Nathan Wright, in effect, who will struggle to get a game this year. Four years worth of value for pick twelve. Pelchen is a genius. Just ask him! And GWS used that same pick #12 on Kristian Jaksch who did bugger all for them and ended up at Carlton where he's s...

No point wasting your time Con. People just don't get it. This is the exact reason why St Kilda is the worst performed club in the history of the comp. By a very long way I might add. People cannot look at the situation objectively because they get attached to players. :roll: At the end of 2017 I w...

Maybe this is the family being reunited that Jaxons et al were referring to a couple of weeks back?

Ah okay thanks saintsRrising, I hadn't twigged to the Richo connection...

http://www.news.com.au/sport/afl/port-adelaide/cam-oshea-is-looking-for-a-new-club-after-announcing-his-time-at-port-adelaide-is-over/news-story/95400af3fb1509dc2648971af1856bd1 "Of O’Shea, who is expected to move to St Kilda, Davies said: “We thank Cam for his service over the past six seasons...

saintspremiers wrote: Stop whinging about qld games. We've played there over the odds for years

Absolute bulls*** but whatever you're telling the story...

No! First time since Suns came into comp that the Saints haven't played up here! And no Gabba game either. sigh... LOL at Round 23 not scheduled. If they are having the stupid bye again then why aren't the times and days done now? RIDICULOUS As a Queenslander pretty disappointed no games at all up ...

Johnny Member wrote:
I remember a Bulldogs fan telling me once that they already had a replacement for Scott West in Daniel Cross.

It's just madness. People fall for this s*** all the time.

I remember people on here telling me (electronically) that we had a ready replacement for Brendan Goddard in Arryn Siposs...

BTW I read your post previously and was very impressed. I just had to acknowledge it this time around. :D well you two can curl up and cuddle all you like But tell me Havent we just given up two round ones in a row???? Given up two round one picks? Nothing of the sort, we deferred one by swapping w...

have we ever recruited a superstar in his prime? we've lost a few, but cant think of any coming in. Does Silvio Foschini count? Steak knives in the Paul Morwood deal (although I did sport Silvio 6 Foschini on my duffel coat for many moons). I miss duffel coats, not just mine but looking at other pe...

He seems to be enjoying a more defined role and the extra responsibility. He's about 24 so he should start stacking a bit more weight. He's an option for that third tall to support CArlisle and Goddard if he can continue to mature as reliable defender who can provide some bounce out of the back. It...

In a year where he's been under increased scrutiny from the opposition after a breakout 50 goal 2015 he's still managed to slot 27.14 from 15 games, a smidge under 2 goals a game (and that's with him often providing a chop out in the ruck for Hickey as well). He's still learning the role to a degree...

Darby Street great he will have us playing finals and winning flags in a jiffy then - because you think he is doing a good job! Oh no we're definitely going to plummet down the ladder and need a new coach and a new rebuild because some nuff nuff on the internet and his wife aren't bedazzled by Rich...

I've never why people think he should be delisted. To me he's always been a really valuable backup as a big backmen. I said I preferred Delaney over Dempster in our 22 because he can shut down the big forward gorrillas and free up our other defenders. His big downside is his disposal which is prett...

No surprise from me - Dempster to retire. I don't think he is in our best 22 anymore. I was thinking Fish to retire too but with Goddard prob not due back until at least halfway through next year, then maybe another year. With Carlisle to take the number 1 forward, that frees Fish up to use his goo...

Screw him anyway he was a gun player at his peak but always seemed like a s*** bloke, always trying to intimidate and demean youngsters from the other side by shoving that big nose in their face and talking tough. I'm glad he went too long and will finish a spud who won nothing hope they get the spo...

There's a some big flaws in Billings' game. That's not to say he is no good, and won't get better. But he needs to improve if he's going to be an A-grader. Can you please elaborate on these "big flaws". I haven't noticed anything particularly significant. In fact, I feel that he reads the...

According to the Hun we have a full squad to pick from for Rd 10 - I debated not posting this because it means we'll almost certainly be decimated by injuries in coming weeks, but it seems quite incredible for this time of year and I was curious as to whether people are putting this down to great wo...

Gun player and his tattoo sleeves represent the duality of man, darkness and light. Every time he kicks a goal it's like a life lesson. Plus I love singing 'Insane in the Membrey' when he jags one (Cypress Hill anyone?)

How would you see him slotting in to our side? Agree he played well yesterday but no way I see him pushing out Membrey or Paddy...

1As I wrote earlier ... forget about this so called 'pride match' for round 20. This week let's bring back some 'fan' pride ... by playing 4 weeks of consistent football. Let's play with pride with wins against bottom teams Essendon and Freo - and Carlton. I can take a loss in Adelaide - but not an...